Jump to content

Helsreach Novel Discussion


Recommended Posts

Wow, thanks for the reminder. I'm way behind on my "books to read" list, but I'm not going to pass up the chance to get this book in my possession ASAP. I missed out on the second "Armageddon" novel because I didn't buy it right away and then it became impossible to find.

How come the PDF extract says it will be £7.99 yet the BL website says £8.99?

 

I read the extract and it was cool, much like ADB's other books. The switching of perspective was odd, past tense, to present, then past etc. It felt like the first Ravenor book.

 

I will be getting it when it becomes available to me even though I can't say I'm a fan of BT. The behaviour of them is very interesting though and ADB talks about this in the podcast he did at Adepticon. It's worth listening to.

Got my copy and I have finished the first chapter.

The brutality of the Chapter is there from the start, as it the knightly ideals. I am wondering where he got his ideas for Grimaldus' ceremony, is this researched from RL orders or is this just something ADB made up? But that whole part is very well done. The only bit that has jarred so far is Kurovs reaction after the BT have offered up there swords, and Priaus sounds a bit like Lucius.

Other than that last bit, excellent so far! Just as I would have imagined them.

Hope it stays the course or gets better.

 

There is one bit so far that will be getting sigged in the next few days.

I am wondering where he got his ideas for Grimaldus' ceremony, is this researched from RL orders or is this just something ADB made up?

 

 

Do you mean the last blow / unanswered blow? Yeah, those used to happen sometimes, back in Ye Olden Days. Kings would do it when they dubbed new knights. As the knight swore fealty, the monarch would strike him, marking the last time he was ever to be struck without hitting back.

 

I am wondering where he got his ideas for Grimaldus' ceremony, is this researched from RL orders or is this just something ADB made up?

 

 

Do you mean the last blow / unanswered blow? Yeah, those used to happen sometimes, back in Ye Olden Days. Kings would do it when they dubbed new knights. As the knight swore fealty, the monarch would strike him, marking the last time he was ever to be struck without hitting back.

 

 

Or, if you like bad movies about Knights - RE: Kingdom of Heaven - "this is so you shall remember it" regarding the backhander following words about duty.. Just to lower the historical tone significantly!

My favourite part so far must have been the scene

in the Cathedral of Sanctuary, as the Templars see Dorn's statue.

The following line was also rather epic:

"...where Astarters of lesser chapters wear the Emperor's Aquila. We do not wear His symbol. We are His symbol."

following line was also rather epic:"

...where Astarters of lesser chapters wear the Emperor's Aquila. We do not wear His symbol. We are His symbol."

That was the bit I was thinking of sigging,

I can just imagine the howls from possible "lesser" Chapters.Loved it! Very BT. And after that Matt Ward qoute that some have in their sigs...

 

 

Do you mean the last blow / unanswered blow? Yeah, those used to happen sometimes, back in Ye Olden Days. Kings would do it when they dubbed new knights. As the knight swore fealty, the monarch would strike him, marking the last time he was ever to be struck without hitting back.

I thought so...

read to much to remember all the customs, some being more brutal than others. this so far at least seems more "real" than some of traditions of other Chapters.

 

 

Chapter 2 and so far so good.

They seem to very much represent the character of Dorn so far. From the brutal undercurrent to the cool, marble like surface, like the fire that Grimaldus was given when told his assignment. Not going to say anything about the other Chapter characters present, I don't know enough about them to really comment, although the SW character seemed right. A bit more on the how and whys of the planning would have been a nice extra, but for some it would argue it the other way.

 

 

Will comment again when I have read a couple more chapters, one at a time will take ages and I am sure others will add anything in-between.

 

Still, that was only chapter 2 and this is the first BT novel in a long time. It has a lot to live up to given that time period where we got nothing. No pressure or anything. :lol:

 

@ Chaptian Juan Juarez: Please consider using "Spoilers", not that your comment gives anything really away, but out of consideration.

Chapter 8 now.

I can't help but think of Fargo and Canadians whenever Andrej talks. EDIT: More of a broken English vibe once I read finished it.

 

 

I like how ADB addresses the different accents of the Imperium in his books. The guy in Cadian Blood was hilarious.

Whoever has not gotten Helsreach needs to go out and get it. I have finished the book and you guys were portrayed as utter badasses. I wish Aaron Dembski-Dowden will write a Blood Angel novel for us... he really did the Black Templars justice in this book.
Whoever has not gotten Helsreach needs to go out and get it. I have finished the book and you guys were portrayed as utter badasses. I wish Aaron Dembski-Dowden will write a Blood Angel novel for us... he really did the Black Templars justice in this book.

 

I already have it on web-order, but thanks for justifying the cost! :)

@ Ash Darke:

Part of me was waiting for him to pull out Mr Hat! "hmm, okay?"

 

 

I am at chapter 10, and with only one or two words that seem to have escaped the editorial process, its been an excellent read so far.

 

One bit I found grating was

the conversation in chapter 3 with the Pricepts, I can understand doing the over lap once, but it did start to get annoying.

 

 

And is the bit about

Oberon new? I have never heard of it before. The bit about its use was also well done, I can see any member of the BT acting in the same way.The last part of Chapter 9 where the fighters launch, I was wondering way the BT didn't send in their Thunder Hawks, if they were gun ships, they would have given the Ork Titans a real head ache.

 

Had a few other :blink: moments, that had me wondering, but some of which was later answered, others had me thinking for a while. Will however remark on the Master of the Forge. Are we going to get one in the next codex, or is this a Master Artificer?

Saving most of my questions till I finish the book.

 

@ Julius Firefocht: There is loads written about the BA, this is the 3rd BT novel (2 of which are long out of print), and hoping for more.

And is the bit about

Oberon new? I have never heard of it before. The bit about its use was also well done, I can see any member of the BT acting in the same way.The last part of Chapter 9 where the fighters launch, I was wondering way the BT didn't send in their Thunder Hawks, if they were gun ships, they would have given the Ork Titans a real head ache.

The bit to which you're referring to isn't new,

there is actually an Epic model of it.

ADB is just including some cool albeit oldish and obscure stuff. He definitely does his research when he writes a book.

 

Here's a link http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Ordinatus_...ddon#Armageddon (tried to spoiler it but it didn't work).

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.