Jump to content

Rules Questions


Caanon04

Recommended Posts

I know at 'ard boyz the questions about Librarian Dreads were answered with regards to wargear. I was wondering as I build my HG were the questions about the blood champion and noviate taking wargear answered there as well? I did not attend 'ard boyz and I haven't heard anything on the subject as of this point.

 

Thanks, Caanon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Champ is not an Honor Guard, therefore he can't take Honor Guard upgrades.

 

It might be legal to take upgrades then become the champ, but I'm always leery of having a situation where the order you take upgrades matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am aware of what the instance in the Codex states. But there are previous situations where upgrade order matters. Like in the Space Marine HG and the Shoota Boy nobz. So, my question is does anyone have a STIPULATED judgement such as the word of a judge at 'ard boyz or things of that nature not personal opinion because there are two camps on this issue.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am aware of what the instance in the Codex states. But there are previous situations where upgrade order matters. Like in the Space Marine HG and the Shoota Boy nobz. So, my question is does anyone have a STIPULATED judgement such as the word of a judge at 'ard boyz or things of that nature not personal opinion because there are two camps on this issue.

Why would a judge at 'ard boyz be a good choice? I bet if the issue came up at 'ard boyz, there would have been different locales giving different rulings on it.

 

This might be one that needs a FAQ.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason I was looking for an opinion of a judge at 'ard boyz is that 'ard boyz is a GW sanctioned event. Therefore if a judge there gives you the go ahead on this issue then that is good enough for me to use that judgement until we get a FAQ. I just don't want to go to my lgs and be like yea this is totally cool, without some sort of base to stand on.

 

Thanks, Caanon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(My Own Opionion follows)

 

Seeing as taking a Blood Champion is the FIRST choice you have in the HG box, I would say even if you are trying to say its an "order mattering" subject then he's first a BChamp, then he can't take anything else. So no. Blood Champs and Sanguinarian Novitiate can not take further upgrades.

 

Another question to you: Why do you need them to have upgrades in the first place? Are 3 Thunderer Hammerers, 3 Meltaguns, 3 Storm Shields, 1 Power Sword (with Combat Shield) FNP, FC, Chapter Banner, and Jump Packs not enough?! ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason I was looking for an opinion of a judge at 'ard boyz is that 'ard boyz is a GW sanctioned event. Therefore if a judge there gives you the go ahead on this issue then that is good enough for me to use that judgement until we get a FAQ. I just don't want to go to my lgs and be like yea this is totally cool, without some sort of base to stand on.

 

Thanks, Caanon

 

Most judges are everyday gamers like you and me with their own rules interpretations. Unless it's in the rules or an FAQ, it's just that, one interpretation. Citing a single judges' ruling at a single tournament really doesn't mean much. I certainly couldn't walk into my lgs with that as my source.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Novit can't. Champion can.

 

Do you have something to back that up? I ask because I looked closely at how upgraded models are worded and those that can be upgraded in some way (like terminator armor for captains) have very clear language, which is why I think the champ, sang nov., and lib furioso cannot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yup. The veteran doesn't replace his equipment when he upgrades, he gains some though. You can technically buy him equipment, then upgrade him.

The Novit isn't a veteran. There's nothing stating he can change his equipment.

 

The Furioso Libby is a bit different. I think the RAI is that he can change equipment, but RAW is murky.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Isn't the wording in C:SM Honour Guard has options "any model" which is much different than ours, but the Command Squad says "any Veteran" which is similar to how the BA codex refers to "Honour Guard." To me, this language does not include the champion.

 

It seems the language in the Ork book is different, and either way, probably shouldn't apply. No similar question was addressed in the C:SM FAQ.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just checked the rules and the options state Honorguard not veterans. Both the champion & novitiate are both Honorguard, just like a veteran sergeant in an assault squad is still an assault Marine. The entry for command squad in Codex Space Marines states that veterans can take the options. Huge difference.

 

0b :cuss

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honour Guard replaces Veterans in our codex.

Honour Guard have a separate statline, along with Blood Champion and Sanguinary Novitiate.

 

The equipment replacements specify that "One Honour Guard...Any Honour Guard." It's referring to the model type, otherwise it would say "One model in the Honour Guard...Any model in the Honour Guard."

 

The Honour Guard that becomes a Blood Champion can have the equipment that any Honour Guard can have, because he becomes a BC by buying the power sword and combat shield. There's nothing that says he loses his previous equipment, otherwise he wouldn't have a ranged weapon (pistol or bolter).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our codex lists Honorguard under the entry for the unit Honorguard as being able to take options. Command squad lists veterans as being able to take options under the Space Marine Command Squad unit. Our HG are the equivalent of Space Marine command squads not Space Marine Honor Guard.

 

0b :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Command squad lists veterans as being able to take options under the Space Marine Command Squad unit. Our HG are the equivalent of Space Marine command squads not Space Marine Honor Guard.

 

0b :D

I don't think I said anything to the contrary of this.

However, our codex muddies the issue a bit by naming both the unit "Honour Guard" and our version of Command Squad veterans "Honour Guard."

I'm saying that, for equipment, only the Honour Guard model type (that's the Honour Guard statline models within the Honour Guard) can utilize the equipment. Sanguinary Novitiates cannot, because while they're in the Honour Guard (unit) they aren't Honour Guard (model/statline type).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Command squad lists veterans as being able to take options under the Space Marine Command Squad unit. Our HG are the equivalent of Space Marine command squads not Space Marine Honor Guard.

 

0b ;)

I don't think I said anything to the contrary of this.

However, our codex muddies the issue a bit by naming both the unit "Honour Guard" and our version of Command Squad veterans "Honour Guard."

I'm saying that, for equipment, only the Honour Guard model type (that's the Honour Guard statline models within the Honour Guard) can utilize the equipment. Sanguinary Novitiates cannot, because while they're in the Honour Guard (unit) they aren't Honour Guard (model/statline type).

 

 

So you'd agree that a Blood Champion cannot, correct? He has neither the name, nor the statline.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He has the name, when he has the Honour Guard statline. He can be given whatever equipment an Honour Guard can. Then you give him a power weapon and combat shield, voila Blood Champion with Honour Guard equipment plus.

As I said, if he didn't keep the equipment from being an Honour Guard he wouldn't have a bolt pistol or bolter, just a PW+CS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.