Black Rage and the Death Watch

[NightrawenII]

Which Index Astartes are you quoting? I have the Index Astartes II, which covers the Grey Knights and Death Watch Chapters and it says nothing of the sort. So without you clarifying where you are getting this, I am ignoring it.

Index Astartes IV, Renegade Space Marine Chapters

 

You missed the point about about Space Marines being above Imperial Rule, meaning no Inquisitors, not High Lords, nothing short of the Emperor.

And you missed the point that Space Marines aren't above Imperial Rule, they are still part of Imperium and therefore subjects of Imperial Rule. Ordo Hereticus was estabilished with the intention to watch and investigate all the subjects of Imperium, including Adeptus Astartes.

 

If this was the Inquisition's forums then we would put that fluff first, but this is the Blood Angel's forums, so guess what? They have the Baals to do anything within the letter of their mandate that they feel the need to. And guess what, you can NEVER win this arguement here. Its really that simple, you lost before you even started you post because it should have dawned on you that both sides have backing fluff that say they are right. So let me repeat it again, when dealing with conflicting fluff people will go with what they like the best because it will seem more logical to them. I.E. here Space Marines win, in Inquisitor Land the Inquisitors win, but we are here and not there.

;)

 

Likewise Night, as much as I agree with your argument starting it all off by calling someone a SM fanboy doesn't make your argument any more convincing, and doing it on a SM forum is rather like a pot calling a kettle black while they're both in the stoveware cupboard.

Okay, I apologize for my tone, but the opinion that Space Marines are Ultimate Awesome, Made of Win and Untouchable annoys me like hell. And this is comming from SM player, mind you.

 

Put it simply the Chapters of Adeptus Astartes, while they hold a lot of political power and prestige, aren't the upper dogs of Imperium. The size of fish is measured by the size of pond and in the pond of Imperium is single Chapter just insignificant little fish. It hurts, I know, but this is undisputable truth.