If you could ask one question of GWs rules team....

[Grey Mage]

What would you ask them to clarify for you? Or alternatively what is one rule that you would want changed, and why?

 

Lets keep it civil- these are personal answers, and so debate should be kept to a minimum. But I think it would be interesting to see what is on each others minds.

[Gentlemanloser]

Please explain how Initiative, Initiative step, Pile in, unwieldy, Set Modifiers to Initiative and Assault Grenades actually work.

 

Or

 

Do you realise how unbalanced Page 7's Codex > Advanced > Basic truly is?

[Dam13n]

I'd settle for:

 

"Could you please actually proof read and thoroughly test out each codex/rulebook before you release it". The poorly worded rules in the 6th ed rulebook and C:CSM just come across as amateurish. Especially as buying said books isn't cheap (I stumped up the cash for the collectors editions of both and do feel somewhat ripped off).

 

Failing that - promptly updated FAQs with answers that actually make sense, rather than contradicting themselves.

 

Of course "What was Mat Ward thinking when he dreamed up mindshackle scarabs/psychotroke grenades?" as both are massively OP.

 

(then again "What was Mat Ward thinking when he applied for a job in games development?" would probably trump that)

 

Laterz...

[JamesI]

What is the point of the "Unusual Power Weapons" rule since every unusual power weapon has been FAQed into a specific power weapon type?

[alex567]

Can you change the rules for ignoring wounds inflicted on models you can't see?

 

OR

 

My purgation are made of win, so why can't my psycannons penetrate walls?

[DarkGuard]

Gold medal to Gentlemanloser for asking the first legit question here. Remember, this is the rules team, not GW, if it were GW in general this would be Amicus. Lets keep this appropriate to the rules forum by asking about rules questions. All non-rules questions (current game rules) have been removed.

[Gurth]

"Why do you insist on tweaking a set of rules that was pretty decent by 1980s/early '90s standards but is now clearly showing its limitations?"

[Spacefrisian]

Why are there grey areas in you rules set.