Jump to content

What do i read next?


The Red Thirst

Recommended Posts

Unless we get a list of every book you have read, we can't exactly say for sure.

 

I will say, of those that you know you have missed, that some of the anthologies had some very good shorts and Unremembered Empire was much, much, much better than Vulkan Lives

It depends on what your interested in. If your looking for HH stuff, then I'd say you've missed alot, but if your looking for legion specific... I'd one of the short stories from Age of Darkness. I forget the title however it is about the Iron Warriors. Thas my two cents...

Iron Within about Dantioch? Didn't really figure into Angel Exterminatus. However, both Reflection Crack'd from The Primarchs anthology and Crimson Fist from the Shadows of Treachery anthology both do lead up into Angels Exterminatus.

Iv read Reflection Cracked but not Crimson Fist, thanks Kol

Funny enough, one I would highly suggest you read before Angel Exterminatus (if you haven't already), would be a 40k novel, Storm of Iron.

 

Matter of fact, I'd say it's mandatory.

U r a sick, twisted and evil individual.

 

 

 

 

Can I have your autograph?

I'm serious. Damn near all the primary characters are in Storm of Iron. Plus, on it's own, it's a great book, if a touch dated.

 

At least I wasn't a jerk, and told him to read all the McNeil Ultramarine books that have the other Iron Warriors in them....

A good read indeed, but as someone interested in military history (and French), I've been annoyed by the fact that a lot of the stuff has been directly taken from Vauban's work : fortress building, siege warfare and even the name of the Castellan...

 

For those interested : Vauban

 

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ac/Tranch%C3%A9es_parall%C3%A8les_Vauban.jpg

Why would it annoy you that a story about a battle between the Iron Warriors and the Imperial Fists, the two foremost siege warfare legions, references an expert on siege warfare to, in all likelihood, add some realism to the siege?

 

Annoyed is maybe a bit strong.

The problem is precisely realism : W40k is not realistic & will never be, so copy - pasting XVII century techniques is kinda ridiculous.

But I repeat, I enjoyed the reading and half of me is really happy with the tribute to a genious like Vauban.

But with Perturabo being Da Vinci's number one superfan, surely it wouldn't be a huge stretch to assume both he and Dorn would have studied classical  writings on the discipline siege warfare?

Since Dorn's original specialty was actually urban warfare, not siege warfare, and it was the Iron Warriors who built the Castellan at Hydra Cordatus, not the Imperial Fists, I'm going to go with "possible, but it is more likely Perturabo studied it."

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.