Jump to content

Recommended Posts

It is called (needles) pedantry guys.

When you're shooting at mono save unit like 3+ or 2+, you really only want two sets of colour dice - one that negates sv one that does not. Why would you ever need a different dice for non penetrating shells?

Oh definitely.

 

But due to Master crafting being a single miss per heavy bolter and not just all missed, they need to be rolled in sets of 3s, further slowing down the game.

It is called (needles) pedantry guys.

When you're shooting at mono save unit like 3+ or 2+, you really only want two sets of colour dice - one that negates sv one that does not. Why would you ever need a different dice for non penetrating shells?

Because every gun only can re-roll one missed shot.

It's like a TSS with Plasma Guns.

Oh, I see.

But it's still quite easy to solve:

Let's say we have full 10 hb squad

0. Roll for AP. 4 HB ignore sv, 6 not.

1. Group your shots - those that ignore sv, those that does not.

So:

Group one 18 shots.

Group two  12 shots.

2.Rerolls:

group one (6hb) - 6rerolls

group two (4hb) - 4 rerolls.

 

I can't see a point of designating reroll to particular heavy bolter when grouped since you're shooting them at the same time. Am I making some mistake in my reasoning?

Edited by rendingon1+

It comes down to probability. Rerolling a flat amount (1per gun) isnt really all that fair (unless both players do it this way) due to one marine possibly rolling 3 1s and only getting 1 reroll while the rest of the squad hits. Using the reroll pool would basically have permitted that one marine to reroll all their misses instead of one.

 

It saves time, sure, but, at the end of the day you might be rerollling more dice than you might have been allowed if you rolled separately.

  • 2 months later...

So I've been looking back over this thread for some 1st legion inspiration in gidy anticipation of some full-bodied rules in the new book coming (soon-ish? in geological time at least!)

and something depthchage suggested with the new legion mortifactor piqued my interest for an in-your-face ironwing list.

It's a silly list idea but I thought i'd share it as the thread is kinda quiet right now.

It's based around the idea of a mortificator charged with the dubious honour making the first breach into an enemy stronghold

The forlorn hope is a mortificator with his charge of 3 cortus dreadnoughts and a recon squad and delegatus in a mastodon.

 

3000 points ironwing.

 

HQ

Delegatus - 115

Artificer armour, refractor field, terranic greatsword, combi-stasis

 

Mortificator - 650

morty, artificer armour, refractor field, combi-stasis, terranic greatsword

with 3 x cortus w/ kheres, chainfist, grav-gun each

 

Troops

2 x tacticalsin multi-melta rhino's - 225 each

sgt. w/ calibanite warblade, melta bombs, combi-stasis and additional cobat blades on the squad.

 

recon squad - 235

combat blades, sgt. w/combi-stasis, calibanite warblade

 

Heavy

Sicaran omega squadron - 440

2 x sicaran omega tank

 

Sicaran punisher squadron - 410

2 x sicaran punisher tank

 

Lord of War

Mastodon heavy assault transport - 700

 

My real hope is that this could work for a dreadwing list once it gets rules as the mad charge described in one of the heresy books by the dreadwing seemed like a true embodiment of grimdark all out war.

 

The recon squad is there to give scout to the mastodon (if it can? can it? i hope it can at least :whistling:)  and maybe take a mid-field/opponents objective and/or act as the sacrificial lamb once the rolling fortress has disgorged the honoured fallen into the heart of the enemy deployment zone.

They've got a rhino so they don't affect the ironwing tanks to other units rule and maybe it could be used to provide some cover for something?

 

The BS5 sicaran squadrons are there for anti-meq & teq (and maybe hope for some rending shorts with the punishers into big hard targets) and i think it's a cool image with a massive assault tank as a point of the spear flanked by fast tanks

 

The two tacticals are because compulsory troops and bjectives.

 

What do you guys think?

I don't have the sicarans or the mastodon, but i'm saving up for a centre piece model at the minute and i love the model and i think this could be a fluffy and cool looking list if it worked?

Maybe something really niche like despoiler tacticals as the only compulsory troops allowed and you get an extra couple of inches for assault and run distances.... but you must have more sword weilding models than all other models on the table or you give away d3 victory points :teehee::facepalm:

So I've been looking back over this thread for some 1st legion inspiration in gidy anticipation of some full-bodied rules in the new book coming (soon-ish? in geological time at least!)

and something depthchage suggested with the new legion mortifactor piqued my interest for an in-your-face ironwing list.

It's a silly list idea but I thought i'd share it as the thread is kinda quiet right now.

It's based around the idea of a mortificator charged with the dubious honour making the first breach into an enemy stronghold

The forlorn hope is a mortificator with his charge of 3 cortus dreadnoughts and a recon squad and delegatus in a mastodon.

 

3000 points ironwing.

 

HQ

Delegatus - 115

Artificer armour, refractor field, terranic greatsword, combi-stasis

 

Mortificator - 650

morty, artificer armour, refractor field, combi-stasis, terranic greatsword

with 3 x cortus w/ kheres, chainfist, grav-gun each

 

Troops

2 x tacticalsin multi-melta rhino's - 225 each

sgt. w/ calibanite warblade, melta bombs, combi-stasis and additional cobat blades on the squad.

 

recon squad - 235

combat blades, sgt. w/combi-stasis, calibanite warblade

 

Heavy

Sicaran omega squadron - 440

2 x sicaran omega tank

 

Sicaran punisher squadron - 410

2 x sicaran punisher tank

 

Lord of War

Mastodon heavy assault transport - 700

 

My real hope is that this could work for a dreadwing list once it gets rules as the mad charge described in one of the heresy books by the dreadwing seemed like a true embodiment of grimdark all out war.

 

The recon squad is there to give scout to the mastodon (if it can? can it? i hope it can at least :whistling:) and maybe take a mid-field/opponents objective and/or act as the sacrificial lamb once the rolling fortress has disgorged the honoured fallen into the heart of the enemy deployment zone.

They've got a rhino so they don't affect the ironwing tanks to other units rule and maybe it could be used to provide some cover for something?

 

The BS5 sicaran squadrons are there for anti-meq & teq (and maybe hope for some rending shorts with the punishers into big hard targets) and i think it's a cool image with a massive assault tank as a point of the spear flanked by fast tanks

 

The two tacticals are because compulsory troops and bjectives.

 

What do you guys think?

I don't have the sicarans or the mastodon, but i'm saving up for a centre piece model at the minute and i love the model and i think this could be a fluffy and cool looking list if it worked?

I could be wrong but don't units only confer rules to dedicated transports? Don't get me wrong I love the Mastodon but it's a waste if you're only putting a recon squad in it.

 

You also don't have much scoring. Opponent could easily shut you down that way.

Edited by ShadowCore67
  • 2 months later...

 

Heavy

Sicaran omega squadron - 440

2 x sicaran omega tank

 

Sicaran punisher squadron - 410

2 x sicaran punisher tank

 

 

 

 

The BS5 sicaran squadrons are there for anti-meq & teq (and maybe hope for some rending shorts with the punishers into big hard targets) and i think it's a cool image with a massive assault tank as a point of the spear flanked by fast tanks

Where does it say you can have squadrons of sicarans?

I keep looking for that and have to assume I missed a FAQ somewhere....

 

Can I put more than one sicaran in each elite slot as squadrons? Is it two or three in the squad?

 

If so, that puts a ridiculous twist on my Armored Breakthrough ROW Army....

I can only field three sicarans in the four elite slots (because i have to keep one open for Terminators with a Spartan, thats just cool), and use one more for the Master of Armor... As is, I can only field 18 predators in the troop slots or swap out two squads for breachers with LR. Elsewhere the heavy slots are taken up with two squads of 3LR and 1 squad of Vindicators. Throw in a Fellblade for good tanky measure...

The new Saber Tank fits super noice into the army FOC as well, because I can throw 6 of them into the fast slots... thats fluffy, right?

 

 

 

 

 

Heavy

Sicaran omega squadron - 440

2 x sicaran omega tank

 

Sicaran punisher squadron - 410

2 x sicaran punisher tank

 

 

 

 

 

The BS5 sicaran squadrons are there for anti-meq & teq (and maybe hope for some rending shorts with the punishers into big hard targets) and i think it's a cool image with a massive assault tank as a point of the spear flanked by fast tanks

Where does it say you can have squadrons of sicarans?

I keep looking for that and have to assume I missed a FAQ somewhere....

 

Can I put more than one sicaran in each elite slot as squadrons? Is it two or three in the squad?

Book 8 has updated rules/points for the Omega, Punisher, and Arcus. It added in the ability for the Omega and Punisher (only those two) to be taken in units of 1-2.
  • 2 months later...

What are your opinions on our three new units? I’d be tempted to replace the interemptors with some MAS HB jetbikes, but they have ignores cover and the FA slots have become pretty contested with using Dreadclaws, sabres, javelins, and termites.

 

I think the inner circle guys are a must and should be used to bully non deathstar units.

 

DAs is looking like shoot anything with a 2+, stab it if it’s got a 3+ or T5+

I think the Inner Circle knights with thunderhammers and the right choice of order are arguably some of the best offensive terminators in the game. Five with all hammers is 5pts less than the same amount of Justaerin with power-fists.

 

In a situation where I know I'll be stuck against some nasty 2+ armour deathstars, I'd definitely consider the all-hammer knights with Breaker of Hordes or Slayers of Kings. Joys of magnetising, in my case!

Depends what you want them to do an vs who. I know I'll use them vs NL guy in my group who runs annoying Curzestar with 20 assaults + characters under terror assault.

I’m curious what your plans are - I have a similar buddy that runs recon company Blood Angels with a giant assault blob and characters. Cover, perdition blades, and FNP are a pain in the ass.

 

Depends what you want them to do an vs who. I know I'll use them vs NL guy in my group who runs annoying Curzestar with 20 assaults + characters under terror assault.

I’m curious what your plans are - I have a similar buddy that runs recon company Blood Angels with a giant assault blob and characters. Cover, perdition blades, and FNP are a pain in the ass.

Weeeell... Not sure yet. Will probably use a hijacked phobos land raider (dude is big on skyfire interceptors) and will try to:

a ) disembrk as close as I can and shoot

b )knowing they willl die anyway charge them to get those rad grenades working

 

Knowing this dude I plan to pull that off turn 2.

I'll keep them at 7, no phospex, no missles, one big gun, attached master of signals (for+1BS and crazy orbital) with artificer, refractor and axe.

Of course there will be other heavy hitting unit: cenobium(?hmmmmm) or some cortus talon. One stasis shot from any source will be necessary too.

 

Ehhh... Scrap that. I did the math, not enough damage from the interemptors, lot of maneouvring, positioning and counting on my opponent playing curzestar like he did before. I tried to be smart:(

Edited by rendingon1+

Only moritat has that special rule, you can attach any character you like to the destroyer squad :-)

 

I have to think on it, we have a game next monday, last one before the campaign and I really need that victory :-D

Good news is no LoWs of any kind on campaign haha

Tommorow I'll come here with a mindblowing solution, be sure of that.

 

What can you expect of your BA opponent listwise? Are you dead set on interemptors?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.