Jump to content

Recommended Posts

You have to roll 4+ to do it so you will fail half the time. And only if you don't have any wounded guys. And they are already expensive then you lump an apothecary or more on them that will literally do nothing half the time. Not a recipe for success. But if you can boss 4 ups then go for it!

I just played a 2000pt DA Battle Company list and destroyed some Eldar, he has usually caused me grief but this time I took no vehicles. Excellent move Stobz ;)

 

Master

Interrogator with jump pack.

 

6x full Tactical Squads,all Sgts Combi plasma, 2x Lascan&melta, 2x Plascan&plasgun, 2x Gravcan&plasgun

 

2x half Assault Squads, Sgts Plaspistol&power sword, 2x flamers

 

2x full Devastator Squads,each with 2x Lascan and 2x Plascan.

unless he played wave serpent spam or dark reaper spam, eldar are not that strong. Wraithknight a are waaaaay over priced now. His list has plenty of weapons that just wreck eldar and without wave serpents literally just foot slogging. Be interested to know opponents list

Opponent was not optimal but I was still happy with my infantry parking lot. Damage output was killing stuff at all ranges and resilience was excellent.

He had (something like):
Avatar
Wraithlord
War walkers
Far Seer
Three Waveserpents
Falcon
Banshees, Dragons, etc.

I dropped all but one serpent and one walker, while still having 52 men left.
I may tweak it a bit with a Lt when they are available as non Primaris. And a few more LCs and less PCs.

It's been nice trying new options, except at the top tables there are many options that can win.

Edited by Interrogator Stobz

Few different reasons combine to make them quite good:

They can move 80" when they advance.

Their weapons are assault, and automatically hit as they are Heavy D-scythes. They get 2D3 shots total, which can put some massive hurt out.

They have Spirit Stones.

They have a -1Ld bubble.

 

Most importantly though: they are psykers, and can cast Conceal on themselves.

 

All in all, it is a very durable, high wound output model that has insane flexibility.

Edited by Brother-Captain Sharp
A lot of talk is about horde armies (Tyrannids, Orcs, etc) being really viable in 8th. So what about Whirlwinds? Templates and Scatter Dice are no longer a problem, artillery hits where you put it, indirect fire is a reality, so you can hide and shoot, and we may anticipate a stratagem like Space Marines where we can use Landspeeders as spotters. Is massed artillery fire the solution for hoard armies?

Do the math on the Whirlwinds options, they are not good at actual damage output. 2D6 shots have a tonne of variance but will average 8(7.5). They will hit with 5(4.95), they will wound T3 with 4(4.16), if the hordes have crap armour and/or are in cover and save at 5+ they will take 3(2.73) casualties, so maybe 9 points of dead conscripts for your 100ish point Death dealing monster of doom.

Over 6 turns, 54 points earned back.

 

TL/DR: They suck more now. GW, please change these, please.


They should get D6+6 shots imho.

I think artillery is a bit of a trap to be honest.  Maybe guard can make it work, but not as the sole point of the army.  They are cheap enough for Guard to run as a detachment, along with some other parts (Like Brandon Grant's list that won BAO).  For marines, I think it's lacklustre,  and you really have to dig into Forgeworld to even make it semi viable (which might not be an option due to cost, availability of models, or local comps that ban or limit FW).

 

As stobz says, they seem impressive, and ability to hit anything without LOS is so tempting, but if you math it, it's not that good, and if you play it, you will see it backs up the math.  My own list for example, not scared at all about artilery, I will happily sit there and just kill the rest of the army and leave the immobile artillery maybe plinking a few wounds off every turn. And other than that, it is doing nothing. Its not getting objectives (other than the one you probably placed in your own zone) and it requires an investment in bubble wrapping (or else a single 70 point eversor will ruin your day).

 

The FW whirlwind variants are probably the best artillery that marines have access to if you are gonna do it.  Quad mortars aren't bad, but i'd rather take heavy bolters on a razorback and have it mobile and be able to transport troops.  thats my 2 cents on artillery

Would they be better if DA would get a similar Stratagem as SM, Datalink Telesomething. 1CP if any Land Speeder (keyword) is within 12" of an enemy and has LoS, then the WW hits automatically. I suppose SM still have an edge because of LSS, but RW may get something to make Speeders more viable. In the worst case you could use a DS as a spotter.
Still not impressed even with the strategem, how long can you keep a Speeder within 12" of something, one maybe two turns in a game. That equates to another fourish dead conscripts for sacrificing a speeder... Not for me thanks ;)

I don't really rate the Whirlwind any more, or many of the indirect fire artillery weapons, but if you can re-roll them, or you have several of them, or you're Guard, then they get better. All the times I've faced them this edition they've seemed lacklustre - except the Manticore.

  • 2 weeks later...

Hey guys,

 

Been super busy at work the last month or so.

 

Things should hopefully get back to normal next week and I can keep updating this guide.

 

If anyone has some info on the new Priamris units that haven't been reviewed yet please reply so I can update it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.