Jump to content

=][= E Tenebrae Lux IV =][=

Captain Semper

Recommended Posts

Kizzdougs Venerable Brother

Kizzdougs

Posted
Posted

I like the 'Artificer' award the way it is. Any painting contest will always be subjective and ultimately come down to the judges personal preference. I think we can all trust Semper to be as impartial as humanly possible. There was a considerable number of worthy entrants this year, but I'm pretty happy with Semper's selection. I think that limiting the award to three joint, overall winners really helps to give the badge a sense of exclusivity.

 

If we wanted to run a forum by forum contest, it would probably be best to leave it in the hands of the Mods responsible for the specific forums. It could be run as an associated competition. Separate but related.

Augustus b'Raass Venerable Brother

Augustus b'Raass

Posted
Posted

Even though I had the honour of being awarded one, I do think the Artificer Badge is subjective and could be constructed as ´unfair´. Expanding on it would make it even 'unfairer´, especially considering the nature of the BnC and the spirit of the ETL: camaraderie and competition to produce quality miniatures. I can also imagine it to be super hard to pick a favourite for Semper, who's (I'm guessing) the sole judge in awarding it. These are all arguments against the Artificer Badge.

 

On the other hand, it is tradition, and traditions strengthen the feeling of community. So -and I´m directing his mostly to Captain Semper- perhaps you could see the awarding the Artificer Badge like this: as a reward for singlehandedly hosting the largest and best 40K online painting competition on the planet, you get to pick your three favourite miniatures. Turn it around, so to speak: don;t see it as a burden, but as a privilige, which I'm sure the community is very happy to grant you for doing all your work.  

 

As I said, I was very humbled and excited when I found out I got the badge last year, and to me it was certainly an incentive to not let quantity get in the way of quality this year (as I admit did kinda creep into my productivity in the last couple of weeks, last year). 

Adra'Melek Veteran

Adra'Melek

Posted
Posted

Just to be clear. I'm not against them as they are now and it wouldn't mortally offend me if they were expanded. I just wouldn't vote for them myself.  At the moment they're (as Augustus already said) "Captain Semper's 3 units that stood out the most for me" award.

 

I do need to look at more of the forums and hopefully everyone will do a completion showcase as I hadn't seen any of the Blood Angel stuff and the Deredeo is pretty darn nice.  I've only really checked out the chaos one and some of the HH.

CommodusXIII Veteran

CommodusXIII

Posted
Posted

I took my completed vow to my FLGS last night.  Now they know why I've been holed up over the past three months...

 

http://i.imgur.com/e6UC47fl.jpg

 

It was also good practice for transportation to Adepticon next year - though I'll definitely have to invest in some better carrying cases!

Kilofix Venerable Brother

Kilofix

Posted
Posted

I took my completed vow to my FLGS last night.  Now they know why I've been holed up over the past three months...

 

 

http://i.imgur.com/e6UC47fl.jpg

 

It was also good practice for transportation to Adepticon next year - though I'll definitely have to invest in some better carrying cases!

Tell me you wiped out whole companies and regiments, and that there was much weeping and gnashing of teeth, and many a gamer pulled out their neck beards.

Kilofix Venerable Brother

Kilofix

Posted
Posted

Btw, here's what I think about the Artificer award:

 

Who's the one person that puts in all the work around organizing this event and who is it that has to read through and compile each and every post in every forum?

 

If we are to have an Artificer award, then the aforementioned person is probably the most qualified and deserving to award it, even if it is subjective.

 

 

Edit - I just realized that Augustus said the same thing but yeah....

Captain Semper Venerable Brother

Captain Semper

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Thank you guys - I appreciate your views and confidence. This is certainly food for thought for the next ETL - the V anniversary edition! ;)

 

Now let's see more minis painted during ETL IV - I'm un-pinning the main ETL thread on Sunday so let's put some pics in here (it'll still be open for comments mind you but it will not be pinned).

ShVagYeR Veteran

ShVagYeR

Posted
Posted

It was a meager 145 points vow, but I was really happy with how it turned out and it was my first ETL ever, so these bikers will always have a sentimental value. :)

 

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-te4k6nt_sUE/VYr4_nWoXoI/AAAAAAAAKhM/bcmheaascjI/s1600/bikerzygrupowo1.jpg

 

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-HGQTZg9zSU8/VYr4_aunFYI/AAAAAAAAKhI/hsFcTeEGr7Q/s1600/bikerzygrupowo2.jpg

Dantay VI Venerable Brother

Dantay VI

Posted
Posted

Credit where credit is due Captain Semper. You have been fair, quick and consistent in all of your rulings. You evolve the ETL, to keep everyone motivated and you make it a joy to take part in.

You should be rightfully proud of what you have created and nurtured, because I think for many, without the fun, banter and cameraderie of the ETL, a lot of us would have lost all motivation.

So From this Wolf, I say thank you :)

 

I reckon you desreve promotion to Chapter Master ;)

Captain Semper Venerable Brother

Captain Semper

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Thank you Dantay but Master of Recruits is good enough a title. Besides it's only one of the number of convoluted titles that I have as a member of the Inner Circle! ;)

I cannot say any more... ph34r.png

Now put your work here for everyone see! :D

WarriorFish Venerable Brother

WarriorFish

Posted
Posted

Picking favourites is surely Semper's compensation for doing this? tongue.png Here are my vows for this year:

Vow I: Ratlings
gallery_30308_10714_6244.jpg

Vow II: Tank Commander in Demolisher
gallery_30308_10714_154786.png

Vow III: Stormsword
gallery_30308_10714_44742.jpg

Vow IV: Lord Commissar
gallery_30308_10714_32399.jpg

A record four vows, hopefully get five in next year :tu:

Teetengee Venerable Brother

Teetengee

Posted
Posted

Would you consider changing the completion % to a % of vows vs a % of points? I don't know exactly what effect it would have, especially since it might just encourage people to break up large vows, which may or may not be a good thing.

 

Also: Terrible pictures will be replaced by better ones, sometime.....
Vow 1:

Hidden Content
http://i.imgur.com/7ivdArK.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/SUrP7kU.jpg

I feel like a picture is missing here and I don't know why....

 

Vow 2:

Hidden Content
http://i.imgur.com/WuDJK4q.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/E0coYGg.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/3kvtb6N.jpg

 

Vow 3:

Hidden Content
http://i.imgur.com/0RkTqIQ.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/TaXt5ea.jpg
 

Vow 4:

Hidden Content
http://i.imgur.com/p2Jdc9x.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/SIW3vDU.jpg
 

Vow 5:

Hidden Content
http://i.imgur.com/rCkXSJ8.jpg

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.

  I accept