Ahzek451 Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 (edited) Started in late 2nd as it was going out the door, and got full in with 3rd ed. Maybe its just a newbie bias (at the time), but 40k had a lot more wonder to it from roughly 3rd ed thru 5th-ish. Speaking mostly on 3rd/4th era, rulebook rules felt easier to read and follow, simpler(in a good way), but the downside was less FAQ's and balance updates. You would get some designer commentary and amendments in the form of chapter approved books, but FAQ's either rarely came up and you had to wait for the following edition before there were any big balance updates. Both good and bad because anyone could hop in and out without chasing too many books/updates, but then some armies/abilities that were under/overpowered went too long without addressing. Or rules with any room for ambiguity that never got a designers commentary. Feedback and the ability to reach out for questions for GW seemed non-existent. BUT...at the same time, 40k was not as competitive back then. Most of us could figure out in short order how to handle a balance issue or rule ambiguity. Tournaments existed aplenty, just not as strong as it is now. Each local group tended to have their own FAQ. Back to the mystery and aw of it all. It felt better then knowing about the heresy as ancient past and primarchs as myth and legend. We enjoyed just talking about what COULD Be if primarchs came back. But deep down a lot of us enjoyed them being part of the past. For those of us that played chaos, we would make up rules for daemon primarchs. As these were technically the only primarchs still around, albeit some still not being very active. But we imaged them being so powerful that we would never dare to think to play them in normal games, strictly large Apocolypse games. Or...before apoc was even a thing simply called "bring all ya gotz". When FW finally did dive into heresy, it was awesome. And it felt like an appropriate way to get move involved in primarchs vs. their re-introduction in 40k. It was a wild new frontier, seemingly only afforded by "rich kids" or older players that could afford the more expensive resin. 40k was already niche, 30k was a niche in a niche. FW was generally considered 40k+ or add-ons for those with a "few" extra bucks. Having a warhound titan or thunderhawk was a big deal. And bigger yet when the reaver came out. And once more with the warlord. A few people were rolling around with the armourcast titans which was a treat. Seeing some of the thinks like the cannon of khorne in a bring all ya gotz game. I can't recall if flyers were 5th or 6th, but that was a major turn in dynamics. Before the proper introduction of flyers, FW had produced some rules for them that made it a funky thing to deal with. Shortly after that, knights became a thing and once again upended gaming dynamics. I enjoyed competitive tournaments more then as well. Not the super over-the-top overanalyzed overcomplex rat race that is today. I liked to play competitive from a lore perspective, perhaps hamstringing myself by playing only my favorite factions and building balanced army lists from a lore perspective. Probably the greatest offending action then was the min-maxing and anyone trying to fit in any maximized jank through any means necessary, especially through the ally system in later editions, or the occasional unbalanced FW unit and oh yes.... decurions, free daemon summoning, and all that stupid GW was engaging in at the time. To me at least, this was the beginning escalation in the growing tournament mentality and popularity. Having GW have a slower release schedule, less rules-meddling, and slower edition release was bitter sweet. Even in my prime youth years I never felt TOO impatient for my army to get a new model or update. In direct comparison to now it just seems too much too fast. In regards to the rules, what we did indeed want transparency, a way to give GW feedback, and more of a presence with their fans. 8th was a big hit for GW for many reasons, but for a lot of us, it finally felt like they were listening. However, for those of us that lived with GW so long knew such a thing may not last. And in instead of going back, it just...twisted. GW retained a social media presence, but it was more like an advertisement channel vs. true engagement. And while GW DID technically get better at responding to deficiencies, they largely ignored a lot of the big gripes and started catering more to the competitive scene. We did indeed want more engagement and ability to take feedback, but the bug bears of short edition cycles, protracted codex releases, and fixing robust playtesting never materialized. Also there was the shifting extras. Fans said less bloat for things like stratagems, GW said...gotchya....we spread strats across detachments now...oh now there is detachment bloat. *facepalm* guys.....that also implies less bloat in general, not...just shifting the bloat. Model-wise, objectively models have gotten better from a visual standpoint (tactical rock or not). From a customization standpoint, back them conversions seemed a lot more common back then, and encouraged. And there was a certain charm to the older models that just doesn't exist with thew new ones. I miss purchasing individual bits. I would like to hear the reverse, perspective from newer players. Like....for me tau are still the new kids on the block. I remember when hammerheads rolled up on the scene and started punching holes into the once "immortal" land raider. Do tau just stick out in your mind as just another 40k faction? Edited November 10 by Dr_Ruminahui Removed swear dodge 3 2 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194778 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lathe Biosas Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 (edited) I started 40k with one model. Did you read "Master Strategist"? I did. And I turned into a douchbag for multiple editions. I built an Artillery Armoured Company. I took maximum Troops (All Basilisks). Heavy Support ( Griffon Mortar Carriers). Elites (Leman Russ Vanquishers). And some Stormtroopers in a Chimera to hang out with Lord Solar "I go First" Macharius. You remember the pie plates? I got to put them everywhere! I was so happy then. I felt like I had For some reason, I always got really low Sportsmanship Scores at Tournaments. I could never figure out why. But then I built an Iyanden Wraithguard/Wraithlord army. And then Dark Angels Deathwing/Ravenwing. Now I have Custodes. I don't see a pattern. Do you? Maybe I should buy Knights next... Edited November 11 by Firedrake Cordova Fixed image formatting 8 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194780 Share on other sites More sharing options...
SvenIronhand Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 I’m torn. On one hand, I’ve been in the 40K space for 5+ years. But I wouldn’t call myself a “veteran” by any stretch of the imagination. As for opinions of the game, eh. I liked 9th’s core rules, but the codexes added so much stuff on top of it! You had litanies, doctrines, relics, special issue equipment, warlord traits, psychic powers, et cetera, and that’s just for SM! And often, only one or two choices of those various lists were good per se. Sure, there’s something to be said for flavor, but 10th-11th’s simplification of things definitely brought the mental load of each game down for me. 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194788 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ahzek451 Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 (edited) 16 hours ago, Inquisitor_Lensoven said: i liked it when they printed rules for building your own vehicles. Silly me, how could I forget VDR. Too poor to afford a warhound titan, find a AT-AT at a garage sale, slap some guns on it, put an egyptian headress on it(thousand sons), and BAM, Titan. Also forgot terrain used to be more interesting before "official" layouts became the norm. Much more terrain diversity. +1 to those talking about the lore. GW is writing things akin to WWE hero time. We focus on the same group of characters that seemingly can appear anywhere and when you do this, you make one of your most notable features(a massive universe) become very small and boring. The lore had more weight back then, the current lore reeks of sanitized corporate influence. Edited November 10 by Ahzek451 2 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194795 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Karhedron Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 8 hours ago, Brother Lutheriel said: 1. What did terrain used to do? When providing cover, terrain usually used to provide a fixed 5+ Invulnerable save. This was back when the AP system meant you usually got your full save or no save at all with no in between. This meant that cover was great for horde armies but provided no benefit for armies like Marines unless they were getting hit with plasma or lascannons. 8 hours ago, Brother Lutheriel said: 3. What’s a skew list? A skew list was one what specialised in one type of unit in an attempt to overwhelm the enemy's ability to cope with that type of unit. Back then, most armies were built using the Force Organisation Chart so usually everyone had infantry as the core of the armies with only limited numbers of elites or vehicles. Early examples of skew lists were things like Imperial Guard armoured companies where tanks did a lot of heavy lifting and the infantry were usually kept safely in transports. Back then, small arms couldn't hurt most vehicles at all which meant that unless your opponent had brought enough anti-tank guns to reliable crack at least a couple of Transports per turn, large portions of their army would be useless. It isn't fun playing a game where a significant part of your army cannot interact with the enemy. Fish of Fury and Serpents of Fury were Tau and Eldar takes on the same principle and were very effective if probably not very fun to face. I had a full Serpents of Fury army which I only used when training or playing in a tournament. I sort of retired it to focus on Marine armies because whilst it won games, I ended up feeling bad using it. 1 2 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194797 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Grand Master Laertes Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 20 minutes ago, Ahzek451 said: Also forgot terrain used to be more interesting before "official" layouts became the norm. Much more terrain diversity. +1 to those talking about the lore. GW is writing things akin to WWE hero time. We focus on the same group of characters that seemingly can appear anywhere and when you do this, you make one of your most notable features(a massive universe) become very small and boring. The lore had more weight back then, the current lore reeks of sanitized corporate influence. In 6th we even had "Stronghold Assault", a whole book of terrains datasheets and detachments, terrain-themed missions on top of it. I loved it (even though it sadly didn't introduce new terrains as it was originally supposed to do). As for the lore, I also loved when the focus wasn't on the present time, but on events happened centuries or millennia before. Among my favourite old books there are the 2nd edition Codex Assassins and Codex Sisters of Battle, that focus on the Age of Apostasy and the Reign of Blood 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194798 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ahzek451 Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 Core memory unlocked: I hate...hate...HATE Crystal targeting matrix. Those that know, know. 1 3 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194801 Share on other sites More sharing options...
NovemberIX Posted November 10 Share Posted November 10 I was originally introduced to the game in 3rd, but didn't start playing and collecting till 5th. Forgeworld was in full swing, Badab War had just come out and only a couple of years out from the Horus Heresy, Apocalypse had some fun formations and unique units like the Land Raider Ares. Sure there was some nonsense, like the Ward fluff, but that was "balanced" out by wild rules like deepstriking Land Raiders. Admittedly, some stuff was less fun than others, armor facings could end up biting you from behind (literally) and AV 14 required preparation during list building. Kitbashing was dead easy though, and getting a full bitzbox wasn't hard at least. Related to formations in 7th, I still feel bad about the time I brought a Gladius Strike Force (full marine battle company with free transports) because I thought I was gonna fight our groups Tau tactical genius, and instead steam rolled our GK guy. I do regret never running a Skyhammer Annihilation Force (2X Assault Squads 2X Drop Pod Devastators turn one alpha strike), but the Suppression Force (Land Speeder Spotter for Whirlwind squadron) that came over from Apoc was really nice, The Heresy launch felt pretty major, and I've been lucky enough to collect most of my favorite units. I wish I could have bought the black books or Imperial Armor vol.2 2nd edition, I love the depth they go into for each type of machine in IA2.2, Badab War had some really awesome HQ characters you could use, and of course the Heresy Black books were full of amazing lore. Had some amazing games during 7th, a lot of 2v2 or 1v1v1v1 Apocalypse that would run all day. I remember one game specifically, it was 1v2. My DIY marines vs GK and BT. They were trying to take and hold some buildings in an attempt to "hack the database" by turn 3 they had 3 of the 5 buildings and we conferred really quick, and agreed if a building was the objective, and buildings could be destroyed, that meant objectives could be destroyed. So my Fellblades and Knights took aim at our own buildings to deny the enemy intelligence. I still lost, but in a way, I feel like I won I actually liked the index start for 8th, because it brought back a bunch of options that had been missing for a couple of editions like jump pack and biker Librarians, though again, you had some cheese like the Loyal 32 (an allied force of IG that worked as a command point generator for Imperial Armies). GW had some amazing Semi-official kitbashes, like the aforementioned Land Raider Ares. A fusion of the Land Raider kit and demolisher cannon from a Vindicator . There was also the Razorback Rikarius which was equipped with a FW siege shield and armor kit with Twin Linked Assault Cannons, and the Hurricane Bolter sponsons from a Storm Raven. The Chapter Approved 2017 Land Raider variants that had come out much later were also pretty nice, but a little late for me to really want to build and buy into after getting burned by said Ares and Rikarious not getting rules as editions rolled over. I think one thing that's changed is there used to be a feeling of really making your guys unique or personalized even if they weren't a DIY force. You were encouraged to kitbash stuff like Fantasy Kits with IG arms to make a different regiments. With the way models are made now everything is so monopose. It feels like everyone is building and painting the same set of Ultramarines with a minimum of variety. If that's due to the Tournamentification of 40K, I don't know, but I can say the game and things around it have changed. 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194809 Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoriyaSchism Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 (edited) I started with 3.5 and 4th edition nearly 20 years ago and I've been in the hobby on and off with a long absence between 5th and 7th Editions. I've played the game the most during 4th Edition. Since I moved to a more rural area I had very few opportunities to play the game. Most of my work has been focused on the modelling aspect of the hobby. What I enjoyed about the initial releases of the Heresy novels and the Black Books is the separation they had. The accounts from the FW Black Books were done in the style of second hand retelling with sparse first person accounts in contrast to how the story was presented in the novels. It's sad that the supplements from Heresy 2.0 didn't carry on that style of story telling. The way the Black Books were presented gave you so much freedom to do your own thing in the turbulent years of the Heresy while still respecting the constraints of the Horus Heresy as an event. My favourite aspects of the hobby back then was the focus on conversions and the guides that were up on the old website. I used to copy those from the internet into a Word document, but I lost all that when my old PC's HDD died. Every codex had a section with some interesting conversion or paint job and White Dwarf articles used to have examples of narrative-based conversions. The old How To Paint Citadel Miniatures guide books were quite good. Chapter Approved was really great and I still play around with the custom unit and vehicle rules from that to this day. I don't get many chances to play outside of tabletop simulator, but I enjoy working with the older system. It feels more free than today's detachments and other nonsense that feels like I'm getting boxed in. My favourite period predates the Horus Heresy as the game system and many of the HH units came from the initial batch of Imperial Armour releases for Space Marines. It's sad that the Heresy today is moving away from that aesthetic. It no longer feels like the mythical past of the original setting, it is starting to look like some alternate universe instead. Edited November 11 by MoriyaSchism 2 1 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194818 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Antarius Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 2nd edition was the start for me (I'd gotten into WFB a few years before). The humorous answer to the OP's question is "the best was some unspecified time in the past, the worst is always right now" and to some extent, I think people (myself included) tend to smooth over the horrors of the past quite a bit. There were lots and lots of things to complain about back then, too. As long as I've been in it, complaining has been a part of the hobby - indeed, for some people, it seems like it's the majority of the hobby and as far as I can tell that's the way it's always been. The certainties of life seem to be Death, taxes and complaints about GW prices/rules/lore/minis/etc./etc. That being said, I have plenty of complaints myself. I played a couple of games this weekend and while I can't say anything was bad exactly, it was just not very fun and didn't really feel like a cool futuristic battle, despite having painted, thematic armies and terrain. To some degree this was down to myself and my opponent not playing every week and thus being a little bit rusty on the various stratagems etc., but overall I just couldn't shake the feeling that the game itself was rather unsatisfying - and this was despite winning both games, just in case anyone's wondering. Obviously, I've gotten older and stupider, but still; the game feels like more of a chore and a lot of bookkeeping than before, despite many of the new ideas being genuinely good (I like the idea of how missions work, stratagems, etc., but the implementation just feels clunky and overly complex for no perceptible gain). Of course familiarity plays a role but it did seem to me that we'd have been able to play an older edition much quicker and more smoothly. The appification is a major gripe for me too. It's just a matter of taste, but to me it takes attention away from the game and the person you're playing with in a manner that's 100% detrimental. Ruleswise, I'd say 4th edition is where things really peaked for me; there were issues of course, but they seemed easily fixable with house rules and the imbalances did not seem bad to me at the time (wargear costs were a bit silly sometimes was my main gripe, I think). 5th introduced the annoying "wound allocation mini-game" and, while the game design was solid the game as a whole took a more "gamey" direction that I didn't personally care for (but I still had plenty of fun games). Lorewise, I've pretty much tuned out since the return of Guilliman. Primaris never really entered my personal lore because the idea is just fundamentally silly and un-40K to me, personally. No complaints about the minis though (apart of course from the Desolators or whatever they're called, because man...); I just trim them a bit and slap older helmets on them and they're the best Space Marines I've ever seen. Obviously, a rescale would have been preferable, but eh, this gives me some fun modelling to do so it's not a big deal to me. There are clunkers here and there, of course, but when I look back at the GW ranges over the years, I do genuinely think the 40K models are overall better today (with several notable exceptions, of course). My main gripe with the designs these days is the tendency to slap on unnecessary detail that take away from the overall impression, but like I said, I just see that as a modelling project. Overall, my philosophy when it comes to the hobby is "take what you need and leave the rest" (to quote the band) and don't mind the internet too much. People will tell you all sorts of silly stuff about what can/can't be done and what units are/aren't playable, but at the end of the day, if you find good friends and aren't afraid to use your mind and creativity to make things work, you can. I am somewhat considering going back to a previous edition of the game though, probably 4th, but we'll see. I suspect my friends will not really feel the need, but otoh they might be up for it and counts-as/house ruling should enable us to use some of the cool new units that didn't exist back then. We've done something similar with Blood Bowl and that's just a massively improved experience. 1 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194820 Share on other sites More sharing options...
apologist Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 What an interesting idea for a thread – thanks Brother Lutheriel. Those who have posted so far in this thread have answered very elegantly and affectionately about the ups and downs of 40k. It's been a treat to see the variety and depth of the answers – as well as drawing out some common threads from those Brethren with a few service studs in their heads. +++ + Space to explore + I wanted to post with some thoughts, but found myself going round in circles trying to figure out quite where to start answering! 40k's a huge arena, and the sense of scale is perhaps a good way in. Looking back now on the 80s and 90s, it's interesting to have the broader perspective of where Warhammer 40k fits into broader sci-fi. Like lots of our cohort, 40k came into my life around the time television and film was filled with space adventures – and a game that had a spiky subversive architecture (what has come to be called 'Grimdark') was an exciting development of the sort of grubby anti-authoritarian sci-fi (2000AD, Aeon Flux etc.) that was still evolving from the optimistic 50s and 60s. Anyway, the great appeal of 40k for me was always that sense of space. That great yawning emptiness (and 'safely miniature danger') was hammered into players from the original tagline – a sentence that has been trimmed off in the more recent editions: 'But the galaxy is a big place, and whatever happens, you will not be missed.' I don't think that really stuck with me at the time – I was far more into the cool space knights and bug-eyed monsters rather than looking for any philosophy – but the fact that the game came in with that sense of wilderness and opportunity for creativity and exploration was a huge part of the appeal. The other aspect for me was that the artwork was so varied and immersive and weird – looking back, the 70s and 80s it was a real golden age for sci-fi art, and WH40k's sails were filled out with that visual imagination. To look at the change in the nature of 40k of time, for me the artwork is the real bellwether. Early 40k had such varied styles. I remember genuinely feeling uncomfortable looking at John Blanche and Ian Miller's esoterica, or really gripped by Gary Harrod's distinctive style – and it's the reason that I those artworks stuck with me. Today, the artwork is generally more polished and refined. It's much more clearly commercial, focussing much more heavily on showing the models rather than expanding the universe. That's not to say it's bad – there are still some great artworks today, and there are none of the clunky amateurish pieces you'd see back in the 90s – but it certainly doesn't grip me in the same way. The technical improvements mean there's less imaginative work I need to do. I look at the battle scene and nod, rather than spot something that draws me in. Far worse than blander artworks is the absence of it, or its replacement with edited miniatures pictures. The Legions Imperialis rulebook is the absolute nadir of the trend for me, particularly when contrasted with its predecessors. +++ + Spelling things out + Being written in the 80s and 90s by a bunch of (mostly) lads (mostly) in their 20s – and for an audience of the same as well as teenagers, there was still lots of silliness in Rogue Trader and 2nd edition, and a real sense of exploration, creativity, make-do-and-mend and inclusiveness. The rules writers were named, and hobbyists like yourself. It was occasionally made explicit that (horror of horrors!) their rules weren't, in fact, the law; and you and your mates should adapt, tweak and change them entirely – but I think that sense of shared ownership, and expectation that readers were entirely capable of doing their own thing, was implicit anyway. That mindset hasn't gone away entirely – there are lots of amazing artists and creators in the hobby, and doubtless many, many more who don't share their stuff online – but the overall presentation of 40k from GW is much more polished, and with it has come the audience's weird sense of reverence for the rulebooks, and expectation that things will be mapped out entirely: literally in the case of the galaxy, and metaphorically in how you're invited to share the game. It's a very 40k twist for any group when the game moves from toolbox to pre-fab; or in other words, what was intended as a starting point for you to build on has become a venerated cathedral that can only altered except by nebulous authority figures every six months. Personally I'd like GW to row back on the technical side of the writing and embrace that discursive, friendly, art-led style of rulebook again, just to remind people of the appeal of social tabletop wargaming in comparison to (say) computer games. You don't need any qualifications or equipment to tweak the rules of a wargame. Having everything spelled out and accessible – from rulesets to painting schemes – is undoubtedly useful to bring people in, but without the sense of ownership that creating your own Chapter/warband/paintscheme, I do think that the (very well-intentioned) accessibility fights against the appeal of collecting your own little toy soldiers to explore your own little corner of the Dark Millennium. +++ + Simulation versus game + In fairness to GW, I think they still talk the talk about it being your hobby. The personalities involved are still keen for people to be creative and riff on things, but the scale of the business now means that they can genuinely expand and build and sell all the things that once would have been the realm of kitbashing and conversion. Scratchbuilt Titans and Gargants and tanks, for example, have always been around – I certainly made a few myself – but I think the collective urge to do so has been pushed back a bit in the hobby by the availability of off-the-shelf kits, and the level of detail in the models. I was absurdly proud of the (dreadful) cardboard tanks I made to give my Imperial Guard a fighting chance against my brother's orks, but I think I would have been put off developing the scratchbuilding and conversion skills if there had been such a range of models as are available. +++ + Simulation versus game + As a couple of Fraters have noted above, complaints and suggestions for change have always been part of 40k and the community. It's a sign that people care enough to want to engage with it! I played every edition from RT through to 8th or 9th, but most around 3–6th. I remember wishing GW would get rid of templates and tighten things up, and discussing with my gaming group how they could write their rules more clearly, so things would be 'fairer' and clearer... but now that I've got that, the game seems weirdly abstract and 'light'. Careful what you wish for, I guess! That lack of engagement and feeling that the models are just game tokens rather than anchors for imagination, coupled with the mechanics not really reflecting how I'd expect things to work, and getting tweaked and refined and updated far more often than I get to play, has meant that I've walked back from 40k recently, as I feel the rules have become more and more distanced from what's happening with the models on the table. Happily, the 40k universe is hugely expansive, and there are lots of ways to be involved, from other games old and new (like Epic) to books and online discussion. Ultimately, I guess, 40k was a more grown-up version of playing with my spacemen and alien toys, and a great way to meet up with friends and meet new people. It is still that. Giving some structure to imaginative play is great, particularly when you're growing up – and that tension between 'playtime' and 'serious stuff' has been in the game ever since. It's in every aspect, from the way the rules are written; the variety and weight of the artwork compared with the text; to the models themselves. Today we're in the happy place that all the old editions are now 'complete', and often have frothingly enthusiastic online communities that have adapted and refined things to their own taste; and are very welcoming. Modern 40k is still a great gateway into tabletop wargaming, and long may it continue to be so. I hope it continues to adapt and change and grow for every new generation for a long time to come! 2 2 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194849 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Magos Takatus Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 (edited) 16 hours ago, Ahzek451 said: Core memory unlocked: I hate...hate...HATE Crystal targeting matrix. Those that know, know. I..... there have been some many rules for Eldar that have been called "Crystal Targeting Matrix" or "Vectored Engines" that do wildly different things that I don't even know the reference. I started playing in 2nd edition and I think the targeting matrix just negated movement penalties when shooting or something like that, but I'm assuming it was something more egregious like move-shoot-move? I think a lot of people here have very fond memories of 3rd edition but for me it almost made me quit the hobby. The generous lore for each army from 2nd edition was culled from each codex, giving you a thin pamphlet with very little in the way of lore (though there was more available in other resources), it completely changed how infantry armour worked, meaning space marines were almost bulletproof most of the time but a large chunk of armies almost never got their armour saves at all. They also cut a great deal of the options out of each army, with Orks losing almost all of their fun and crazy units and being given "shootas" and "zzap guns" without a lot of the fun stuff they previously had. It took them quite a long time for them to get some of their fun toys back. Then there was the Force Organisation chart, which was modelled roughly off a space marine company organisation and every other race had to be shoehorned into it. They had to keep writing variant army lists because the chart was so inflexible and it forced you to take basic infantry for your army, which depending on your army was either a blessing or a curse. In many cases it even strained against the army background, where Eldar/Aeldari from a Craftworld such as Iyanden or Biel-Tan would normally have a larger number of Wraith units or Aspect Warriors but were forced to take Guardians even when the lore would state (particularly in the case of Iyanden) that their population was dwindling so fielding big hordes of Guardians to pay the troop tax felt wrong. There were also changes to the vehicle rules that made them operate less like vehicles and more like bunkers that could elect to stop shooting their main guns in order to relocate. Of course, a lot of these problems were ironed out over time, but be aware that a lot of the people looking back at the good old days and spurning modern 40k all have different reasons to like or dislike things. I think a lot of improvements were made in the early days of 40k, but I think there were a lot of mis-steps along the way, too. Don't get me started on the "twin linked" rule. It's been an abominable way to make guns less effective in every edition. If you strap two guns together, you fire two bullets. You don't fire one bullet that is either more accurate or more likely to wound. One big change is that older editions had rules that were easy to read but could be prone to interpretation or may not be so watertight. In comparison modern 40k rules are probably tighter but every rule feels like a legal document because it's written in weird legalese. It makes the rule less open to abuse, but it does make you wonder if a real human being wrote the rule sometimes. It also means that sometimes I have to read some rules two or three times before I even understand what the rule is even trying to convey. The main thing to take away is that 40k was a lot messier and unprofessional in the past but exploring it felt more like an adventure. Nowadays it is definitely more of a product. I advise you dip your toes into oldhammer. From Rogue Trader and 2nd edition's exploration and foundation of the setting, from 3rd to 5th edition where the game setting crystallised, 6th and 7th edition where they got more experimental, causing both great and terrible things to occur, and 8th edition onwards, which is where modern 40k was really established. You'll probably find things about each era which you love and things that you can't stand but it's nice to have a better understanding of the history. Edited November 11 by Magos Takatus 1 2 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194859 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Griefbringer Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 52 minutes ago, Magos Takatus said: I..... there have been some many rules for Eldar that have been called "Crystal Targeting Matrix" or "Vectored Engines" that do wildly different things that I don't even know the reference. I started playing in 2nd edition and I think the targeting matrix just negated movement penalties when shooting or something like that, but I'm assuming it was something more egregious like move-shoot-move? I tried to hunt down the 2nd edition Crystal Targeting Matrix rules - apparently they were only included in the detachable card section in White Dwarf 207. I do have a copy of that issue, but being second-hand it came without the cards. I do however have the other set of Eldar vehicle cards that came a bit later in White Dwarf 216 (together with the Falcon datafax). Those days of "Cardhammer" sometimes make things difficult to track down, as a lot of information is not included in the actual books but in the separate cards that came here and there. 3rd edition rules for the Crystal Targeting Matrix are more conveniently located in the actual codex (which could have been better organised - vehicle upgrades have rules on page 36, but point costs on page 5). Back then it would allow the vehicle to fire in the middle of movement, for the move-shoot-move shenanigans. Which probably involved moving so as to be out of enemy line-of-sight at the beginning and end of the move. No doubt annoying for the enemy, especially since the 3rd edition had done away with overwatch rules that existed in the 2nd edition. 4th edition Eldar codex has a more limited selection of vehicle upgrades, with the Crystal Targeting Matrix being conspicuously absent. Perhaps the designers had eventually come to a different perspective on the idea? 2 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194875 Share on other sites More sharing options...
techsoldaten Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 17 hours ago, Karhedron said: A skew list was one what specialised in one type of unit in an attempt to overwhelm the enemy's ability to cope with that type of unit. Back then, most armies were built using the Force Organisation Chart so usually everyone had infantry as the core of the armies with only limited numbers of elites or vehicles. Skew lists never went away. The detachments and the loss of the FOC opened up so many possibilities. https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388472-black-legion-gunline-in-11th/page/2/#findComment-6194370 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194876 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Karhedron Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 53 minutes ago, techsoldaten said: Skew lists never went away. The detachments and the loss of the FOC opened up so many possibilities. https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388472-black-legion-gunline-in-11th/page/2/#findComment-6194370 You are right of course. The difference in modern editions is that skew lists based around vehicles/monsters/titanic units are less dominating than in past editions simply because even a lasgun can wound everything on a 6. While not ideal from a realism point of view, I think it is a necessary compromise for a game that tries to cover every type of army from Ork hordes to Knight lances. Ironically I have long played Space Marine skew lists to some extent. Blood Angels are fast enough to field an all-infantry force with no need for Transports and with the heavy weapons carried by boots on the ground. This means that my opponent's anti-tank weapons are somewhat wasted as there are few models in the army with more than 3 wounds. 2 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194891 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Firedrake Cordova Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 I came into the hobby in the early 1990's, via Hero Quest, which led me to WHFB 4th Ed, which in turn led to 40K 2nd Ed and Necromunda. For the plastic kits, for me, there was a peak around the early-to-mid 2000's where they were easy to assemble, and generally rather poseable. The modern kits tend to be more single-pose, and you actually have to read the instructions to work out how they go together - such appears to be the price of the improved detail and sculpting quality. I don't really miss working on the old metal kits - they were harder to clean the mould lines off of, and gluing them together was could be something of a chore (they were more detailed than the contemporary plastics, though). White Dwarf used to have lots of great hobby content, including making terrain, e.g. a ruined city made from the polystyrene box inserts, or an Orc village made from Pringles tubes. GW even made a book on how to scratch-build terrain, which was great. The old battle reports were more narrative, and sometimes a bit mad (look up the "Death of Lord Varlak" battle report in WD 187). All of the month's new releases (none of this weekly release shenanigans) appeared in White Dwarf, the back of which formed a supplement for the catalogues - everything had a part number, and you could order individual models or parts/sprues via mail order. The background was there, and recognisable from today's perspective, but it was less fully-formed. In some ways, that's a good thing, as it gives you more latitude to be creative, on the other hand, if you're not very creative (me!) there's less to help you. Plus, some of the novels that GW has come out with "recently" are genuinely enjoyable (Ciaphas Cain and Eisenhorn series for starters, especially if you can get the audiobooks). 3 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194894 Share on other sites More sharing options...
techsoldaten Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 13 minutes ago, Karhedron said: You are right of course. The difference in modern editions is that skew lists based around vehicles/monsters/titanic units are less dominating than in past editions simply because even a lasgun can wound everything on a 6. While not ideal from a realism point of view, I think it is a necessary compromise for a game that tries to cover every type of army from Ork hordes to Knight lances. Ironically I have long played Space Marine skew lists to some extent. Blood Angels are fast enough to field an all-infantry force with no need for Transports and with the heavy weapons carried by boots on the ground. This means that my opponent's anti-tank weapons are somewhat wasted as there are few models in the army with more than 3 wounds. Yeah, the definition of a skew list as all vehicles / monsters has always irked me. By that definition, every Knight list is a skew list. I prefer to think of them of a concentration of a certain type of unit over other available options. The term only means something in the context of "TAC" or "Balanced," skew is basically the opposite. My current list is a gunline with 18 - 23 lascannons. Played the same in 8th along with a Daemon Primarch + Sorcerer list (usually 8 models total.) Way back in 5th, I played a list with 33 Spawn + 1 CL + 2 CSM squads (who were there specifically to address the FOC and carry melta guns for armor.) Faced a 10-tank IG list in 11th, that's the only other skew list I've seen so far. Skew lists are also notable for running counter to the meta. 11th edition emphasizes copious amounts of cover, which discourages long range firepower as there's no clear line of site across most tables. Finding that opponents tend to organize their lists with this in mind, which often means I have a built-in advantage in that they are generally unprepared. Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194896 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Griefbringer Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 9 minutes ago, Firedrake Cordova said: The old battle reports were more narrative, and sometimes a bit mad (look up the "Death of Lord Varlak" battle report in WD 187). For those wanting to look for it, the official name of this battle report was "Heretic!" (calling it "The Death of Lord Varlak" would have been a bit of a spoiler). A great battle report to read, and the people involved seemed to have a whole lot of fun during the game! Plus the brief background snippets describing Lord Varlak's views on various things make for entertaining reading (it ain't easy being a rogue psyker with separatist tendencies in the 41st millennium Imperium). 1 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194898 Share on other sites More sharing options...
apologist Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 2 hours ago, Magos Takatus said: Then there was the Force Organisation chart, which was modelled roughly off a space marine company organisation and every other race had to be shoehorned into it. They had to keep writing variant army lists because the chart was so inflexible and it forced you to take basic infantry for your army, which depending on your army was either a blessing or a curse. In many cases it even strained against the army background, where Eldar/Aeldari from a Craftworld such as Iyanden or Biel-Tan would normally have a larger number of Wraith units or Aspect Warriors but were forced to take Guardians even when the lore would state (particularly in the case of Iyanden) that their population was dwindling so fielding big hordes of Guardians to pay the troop tax felt wrong. Yes, the Force Organisation chart was a clever idea that was badly – or incompletely – implemented. The standard chart was great for Marines, as @Magos Takatus notes, as it fitted the Company structure. Where the system fell down was in not giving each faction their own faction-specific version. And thinking more about it, it's weird they didn't. There were a number of variants to the Force Org chart from the beginning, mostly related to the mission type; but it would have been much more elegant to have Faction-specific ones. It would have been a simple fix to avoid the Eldar weirdness Takatus outlines, as well as avoiding the need to have awkward kludges like the Imperial Guard platoon system. The percentage system of RT and 2nd edition was clunky and didn't do a great job of steering people to make thematic armies – but even there the 'Black Codex' made alterations to the proportions for different factions, to help account for their different styles of play. 1 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194905 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Griefbringer Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 (edited) 50 minutes ago, apologist said: Yes, the Force Organisation chart was a clever idea that was badly – or incompletely – implemented. The standard chart was great for Marines, as @Magos Takatus notes, as it fitted the Company structure. Where the system fell down was in not giving each faction their own faction-specific version. And thinking more about it, it's weird they didn't. There were some factions that got some adjustments to the basic FoC structure. Codex Chaos Marines (2002) allowed Iron Warriors to either use the standard FoC structure, or they could exchange two Fast Attack slots for one extra Heavy Support choice (coincidentally or not, many studio members had their own Iron Warrior forces at the time). On the reverse, Night Lords could exchange two Heavy Support choices for one extra Fast Attack slot (and could take more than 0-1 Raptor squad). Word Bearers could substitute one each of Fast Attck, Elite and Heavy Support slots with three Troops slots. As regards Eldar, they received Codex Craftworld Eldar (2000) supplement for the main Codex Eldar, which provided custom FoC structure for Saim-Hann Wild Riders (1-2 HQ, 0-1 Elites, 2-6 Fast Attack, 0-3 Troops, 0-1 Heavy Support). Other Craftworlds did not get custom FoC variants, but Iyanden and Biel-Tan lists ended ended up moving quite a lot of units around between the slots, e.g. so that in Biel-Tan list most of the aspect warriors ended up as Troops, while in Iyanden list Wraithguard and Wraithlords (!) became Troops. Edited November 11 by Griefbringer 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194916 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Inquisitor_Lensoven Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 49 minutes ago, apologist said: Yes, the Force Organisation chart was a clever idea that was badly – or incompletely – implemented. The standard chart was great for Marines, as @Magos Takatus notes, as it fitted the Company structure. Where the system fell down was in not giving each faction their own faction-specific version. And thinking more about it, it's weird they didn't. There were a number of variants to the Force Org chart from the beginning, mostly related to the mission type; but it would have been much more elegant to have Faction-specific ones. It would have been a simple fix to avoid the Eldar weirdness Takatus outlines, as well as avoiding the need to have awkward kludges like the Imperial Guard platoon system. The percentage system of RT and 2nd edition was clunky and didn't do a great job of steering people to make thematic armies – but even there the 'Black Codex' made alterations to the proportions for different factions, to help account for their different styles of play. I don’t think the platoon system was an awkward way to fit the guard into the old FOC, but an attempt to recreate something like how real militaries structure their forces 1 1 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194917 Share on other sites More sharing options...
phandaal Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 1 hour ago, Firedrake Cordova said: White Dwarf used to have lots of great hobby content, including making terrain, e.g. a ruined city made from the polystyrene box inserts, or an Orc village made from Pringles tubes. GW even made a book on how to scratch-build terrain, which was great. Still have my ancient copy of How to Make Wargames Terrain, complete with a big splotch of impervious black paint right in between the Eldar and Chaos Marines on the cover. I keep it next to my copy of Battle Missions, in which the first words are "A wise man once said, 'Why would anyone ever want to play two games that were exactly the same?'" Hard to imagine products like that coming out in the era of prepainted L-shaped terrain and official GW tournament circuits. I will never stop playing games on characterful battlefields though. 4 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194919 Share on other sites More sharing options...
techsoldaten Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 4 hours ago, Griefbringer said: There were some factions that got some adjustments to the basic FoC structure. Codex Chaos Marines (2002) allowed Iron Warriors to either use the standard FoC structure, or they could exchange two Fast Attack slots for one extra Heavy Support choice (coincidentally or not, many studio members had their own Iron Warrior forces at the time). On the reverse, Night Lords could exchange two Heavy Support choices for one extra Fast Attack slot (and could take more than 0-1 Raptor squad). Word Bearers could substitute one each of Fast Attck, Elite and Heavy Support slots with three Troops slots. As regards Eldar, they received Codex Craftworld Eldar (2000) supplement for the main Codex Eldar, which provided custom FoC structure for Saim-Hann Wild Riders (1-2 HQ, 0-1 Elites, 2-6 Fast Attack, 0-3 Troops, 0-1 Heavy Support). Other Craftworlds did not get custom FoC variants, but Iyanden and Biel-Tan lists ended ended up moving quite a lot of units around between the slots, e.g. so that in Biel-Tan list most of the aspect warriors ended up as Troops, while in Iyanden list Wraithguard and Wraithlords (!) became Troops. Optimistic we are going to get supplements this edition for the major chapters and legions. The 8th edition Black Legion supplement was actually pretty useful, gave us the Chainlord and some interesting strategems. With the way detchments are organized, you can take as many heavy support / fast attack choices as you want. So it's really a matter of getting rules that actually make the units useful (Raptors could be made a lot better in a Night Lords army.) So it's possible what goes around comes around again. Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194949 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lathe Biosas Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 Since, I have the old guard here, I got some questions: 1. Do you still use the Army names: Eldar, Dark Eldar, and Imperial Guard, instead of the hard to pronounce stuff kids use today? Or have you adapted with the times? 2. Has there ever been a named character model for 40k for Word Bearers or Alpha Legion? 2 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194952 Share on other sites More sharing options...
phandaal Posted November 11 Share Posted November 11 18 minutes ago, Lathe Biosas said: Do you still use the Army names: Eldar, Dark Eldar, and Imperial Guard Why wouldn't we? That is all they have ever been named. 1 3 3 Back to top Link to comment https://bolterandchainsword.com/topic/388779-fireside-chat-with-the-veterans/page/2/#findComment-6194955 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now