Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Vulkan Lives has the dubious honor of being the first HH novel that I got rid of after reading.  Zero interest in re-reading it, and zero interest in even having it around the house.  He managed to take the interaction between the most and least humane primarchs and suck all the life out of it.

 

The B plot in the book was an interesting idea, but the events were stretched out way too long, it could have been dealt with in 50 pages.  Also, eyeballs don't explode in vacuum.

 

Ahriman: Exile was good enough.  The reveal at the end was annoying because there were roughly zero hints about it in the novel, so it came off as more of a 'Ha! Everything you though was wrong, fooled you!'.  

I haven't read very much of his work, but John French is quickly becoming my third favorite Black Library Author.

 

I recently just finished his Horus Heresy short story 'Riven' which follows an Iron Hands ambassador on Terra in search for his brothers. This short story alone has reaffirmed my decision in Iron Hands being my Legion of Choice.

I haven't read very much of his work, but John French is quickly becoming my third favorite Black Library Author.

I recently just finished his Horus Heresy short story 'Riven' which follows an Iron Hands ambassador on Terra in search for his brothers. This short story alone has reaffirmed my decision in Iron Hands being my Legion of Choice.

Says the guy with Sons of Horus in his signature lol tongue.png

Fifteen Hours by Mitchel Scanlon.

 

Fifteen Hours. 

 

Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. Fifteen Hours. 

 

It's pretty good. 

I know the thread is headed in a Heresy direction, but I'll toss another vote out for The Emperor's Gift. Like everyone else around here, I've read most of AD-B's work, and unlike most everyone else, I think this just might be his finest writing to date. Ironic too, considering he was vocal about not being entirely satisfied with its flow. But I love it to bits and it made me seriously consider starting the Emperor's Finest, even with deterrents like the half-cooked Codex fluff and shiny toy syndrome the Grey Knights were still going through. The Emperor's Gift follows a Grey Knight through several actions, full of inter-faction intrigue and politicking. The aftermath of Armageddon is both moving and brutal. It's slower paced, but had much more of an impact on my vision of the 40k-verse than any other shoot 'em up book out there.

But I love it to bits and it made me seriously consider starting the Emperor's Finest, even with deterrents like the half-cooked Codex fluff and shiny toy syndrome the Grey Knights were still going through.

Are you sure, you are talking about The Emperor's Finest? The book does not feature Grey Knights.

The Emperor's Gift is a good read for sure, but for me, its shining moments are the little human-Astartes interaction that ADB also used to such good effect in Helsreach (and the Night Lords trilogy to a different extent).  Hyperion's little psychic brush with the Fenrisian Inquisitor at the most, shall we say, inopportune moment and his reaction to it perfectly encapsulate just how different from baseline humans Space Marines really are.

Heck, Astartes-human interaction is just one of ADB's strengths. Look at The First Heretic.

 

It's not my favorite of his novels, but if you take Chapter 1 in isolation, it's easily for my money the single best chapter Black Library has ever published. Mostly because of said interactions. If it had been released alone as a short story, it would have stood up just fine.

Distant Echos of Old Night was easily the best characterization of the Death Guard so far in the series. Of course, its not exactly a fair fight, the Death Guard have probably the worst showing of any traitor legion yet from BL.

 

Even so, a full length novel from Rob Sanders about the transformation of the Death Guard would be one of the most exciting things to happen to the HH in a long time.

 

Heck, any full length HH novel from Rob Sanders would be amazing. Hopefully his Archaon series will not take up all his time, although Archaon: Everchosen just might be the first WFB novel I pick up.

I'd recommend anything by John French, Chris Wraight, and Andy Smille. They write completely differently to one another, but each one brings something to the table. 

 

 

I know the thread is headed in a Heresy direction, but I'll toss another vote out for The Emperor's Gift. Like everyone else around here, I've read most of AD-B's work, and unlike most everyone else, I think this just might be his finest writing to date. Ironic too, considering he was vocal about not being entirely satisfied with its flow.

 

 

I think it's probably my best prose, but I hate everything I write, so I wouldn't take my opinion on board. It was certainly the most difficult novel to write (until The Talon of Horus) largely because a lot of the time you get caught between what you as an author want to write about and see in the setting, and what fans expect from famous events.

I'd recommend anything by John French, Chris Wraight, and Andy Smille. They write completely differently to one another, but each one brings something to the table. 

 

 

I know the thread is headed in a Heresy direction, but I'll toss another vote out for The Emperor's Gift. Like everyone else around here, I've read most of AD-B's work, and unlike most everyone else, I think this just might be his finest writing to date. Ironic too, considering he was vocal about not being entirely satisfied with its flow.

 

 

I think it's probably my best prose, but I hate everything I write, so I wouldn't take my opinion on board. It was certainly the most difficult novel to write (until The Talon of Horus) largely because a lot of the time you get caught between what you as an author want to write about and see in the setting, and what fans expect from famous events.

 

Hate is the proper mindset for all things Warhammer. Carry on, good sir.

 

 

And a few oldies but goodies from me (maybe the OP's already read them, but they're not on his list):

 

Daemonworld  - forget character development, just revel in the insanity of it all.

Lord of the Night - the Imperium at its worst, schemes within schemes, what't not to love?

Execution Hour - "This novel is a thing of rare beauty." - A D-B.

I'd recommend anything by John French, Chris Wraight, and Andy Smille. They write completely differently to one another, but each one brings something to the table. 

 

 

I know the thread is headed in a Heresy direction, but I'll toss another vote out for The Emperor's Gift. Like everyone else around here, I've read most of AD-B's work, and unlike most everyone else, I think this just might be his finest writing to date. Ironic too, considering he was vocal about not being entirely satisfied with its flow.

 

 

I think it's probably my best prose, but I hate everything I write, so I wouldn't take my opinion on board. It was certainly the most difficult novel to write (until The Talon of Horus) largely because a lot of the time you get caught between what you as an author want to write about and see in the setting, and what fans expect from famous events.

 

Would the main character's lack of enthusiasm about describing the climactic battle on Armageddon be an example of the writer inserting himself into the story? 

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.