Ideally...how many HH books to cover the Siege?

[HeritorA]

Kelborn

'And then comes a new, smaller series called The end of times / The siege of Terra...'

No no - please no. Do not suggest that cheat for them  - they could use it

[HeritorA]

I think, in this case, it's going to be a case of having one's cake and eating it. I can't say exactly what's coming up, and there'll definitely be some things that don't get covered - Sevatar's name came up in the meeting a few times, for example, and I shot that down because there's no time to deal with him, and because me and Alan planned his fate outside the main events of the HH series.

 

But overall, anyone worrying the series will milk the Siege can relax that we won't; anyone worrying it'll end too abruptly can also relax it's not going to. I sense a happy medium coming down the line.

 

 

Crikey. I hope not. It really needs closure.

 

I need closure. I can’t move on unless it’s completed!

 

Having used "Crikey" in a post, you are currently my favourite forumite.

 

Use this power responsibly, for you carry my heart into battle.

 

Hope is a road to disappointment. But I do believe in your good intentions A D-B. Hope GW marketing and selling team do too.

Anyway - whatever the opinion on the serie - you write a high octaine quality stuff. Can't wait to read another good story (especially if that's not a Webway war)

[Mellow]

 

 

Crikey. I hope not. It really needs closure.

 

I need closure. I can’t move on unless it’s completed!

Having used "Crikey" in a post, you are currently my favourite forumite.

 

Use this power responsibly, for you carry my heart into battle.

I shall carry it like a proverbial “Emperors Fulgurite”

 

Alternatively that last line sounds like something Sanguinius would say ... not that you’re writing about Sanguinius in any novel any time soon, right?!

[HeritorA]

 

 

Crikey. I hope not. It really needs closure.

 

I need closure. I can’t move on unless it’s completed!

Having used "Crikey" in a post, you are currently my favourite forumite.

 

Use this power responsibly, for you carry my heart into battle.

I shall carry it like a proverbial “Emperors Fulgurite”

 

Alternatively that last line sounds like something Sanguinius would say ... not that you’re writing about Sanguinius in any novel any time soon, right?!

 

Hinting - aren't you. We all want A D-B pen for the Eternity Gate

[ChildofFang]

Honestly? Awful idea. A collection of books called the Horus Heresy where the finale is in another series? Just from a collectors viewpoint it would be extremely frustrating.

 

As a reader you series are left without a payoff. While not everything needs to be concluded or explained the base storyline has to have a finishing point.

 

The Horus Heresy is the whole series not just season 1, that was the first 20 books, season 2 is the progression to Terra, Season 3 needs to be satisfying in its conclusion.

[HeritorA]

Honestly? Awful idea. A collection of books called the Horus Heresy where the finale is in another series? Just from a collectors viewpoint it would be extremely frustrating.

 

As a reader you series are left without a payoff. While not everything needs to be concluded or explained the base storyline has to have a finishing point.

 

The Horus Heresy is the whole series not just season 1, that was the first 20 books, season 2 is the progression to Terra, Season 3 needs to be satisfying in its conclusion.

If we could separate it by seasons - now we are on the 5th (of we take a 10 books per season). Season 6 would be final for a HH TV show

[ChildofFang]

Maybe, I think you would break it up based on narrative rather than an arbitary number of books.

 

10 show seasons weren’t normal till recently. We could set it at 22 :p

[mc warhammer]

Maybe, I think you would break it up based on narrative rather than an arbitary number of books.

 

10 show seasons weren’t normal till recently. We could set it at 22

 

 

it's actually chicken and egg with this stuff a lot of the time. yeah, a narrative defines a season but the depiction of that narrative is still somewhat driven by episode commission. that's why back in the 22 eps days you had a lot more "filler" or "stand alone" eps in between the overall series arc, which are almost non-existent in the cable and streaming dominated 10 ep seasons of today (at least from the u.s...pretty sure the u.k was always churning out mono digit seasons).

 

the HH is a really hard one to break up into seasons. it'd probs be a bit like vikings: short first season (opening trilogy), longer subsequent seasons. but it does strike me as being a pre hbo structure.

[ChildofFang]

Nah, in the UK they tend to commission and make full seasons of larger numbers, I think the 10 show series in answer to the writer issues and seasons being left Incomplete.

 

Overall the comparison was more about leaving the viewer (reader) completely unsatisfied by having a Horus Heresy collectible series finish in a way that sets up a different collectible series. It would be like firefly stopping where it did purposefully to set up a serenity show that completed the arc.

[Fire Golem]

Shows in the UK tend to be shorter seasons (6, 10 maybe). I can't think of many UK shows that did the 22/24 episode thing.

[hopkins]

http://www.blacklibrary.com/Home/BL-weekender-2017.html

 

Wolf against Wolf - Guy Hayley discusses his new Horus Heresy Novel

 

 

Is this Wolf Cull/Yarant III?

Edited September 30, 2017 by hopkins

[Kelborn]

Think so.

Can't think of anothet Wolf vs Wolf conflict.

[Tymell]

That certainly sounds like it. I'm down with Guy doing it, I feel he's shown throughout the series that he's capable of turning his hand to a wide range of legions and doing them justice. Plus "Twisted" was awesome.

[hopkins]

It's with the editors, so still months away

[DukeLeto69]

http://www.blacklibrary.com/Home/BL-weekender-2017.html

Wolf against Wolf - Guy Hayley discusses his new Horus Heresy Novel

Is this Wolf Cull/Yarant III?

Have they changed the page. Can't find this reference?

 

And...ignore me, it's on the schedule to download! Doh!

Edited September 30, 2017 by DukeLeto69

[Taliesin]

That is pretty damn cool.

[cheywood]

Haley says it's "more exciting than [Yarant]" on twitter. I wonder what that means.

[DukeLeto69]

Haley says it's "more exciting than [Yarant]" on twitter. I wonder what that means.

Yeah he said "Yarant seen nothing yet!" LOL? ... Err ok - get's coat, leaves room in shame shaking his head at the horror of a Dad joke!

[b1soul]

Are we sure that Wolf vs. Wolf has to mean SW vs. (former) Luna Wolves?

[Kelborn]

Do you have anything in particluar in mind, b1soul?

 

If it's not SW vs. SoH, then it mislead quite heavily.

[bluntblade]

There is a mention in a Forge World book of Wolves on the Traitor side.

[HeritorA]

http://www.blacklibrary.com/Home/BL-weekender-2017.html

 

Wolf against Wolf - Guy Hayley discusses his new Horus Heresy Novel

 

 

Is this Wolf Cull/Yarant III?

Yeap. That's exactly what Laurie intended for Russ hammering at the hands of Horus and getting to the point of Yarant where Corax has found him in 'Weregeld'

 

There is a mention in a Forge World book of Wolves on the Traitor side.

 

Nope.

That's exactly the Wolf Cull Laurie has talked about.

[b1soul]

As blunblade says...there are Traitor Wolves

[Roomsky]

As blunblade says...there are Traitor Wolves

 

Honestly I'd be a little disappointed. Not in such a story per say, but that it lies in a novel instead of a short/novella. Unless its some Alpha Legionaries in disguise or something.

 

That said, I've been excited for Russ taking the fight to Horus for quite some time, and after Twisted, I'm expecting some superlative Sons of Horus stuff.

[Mellow]

Was Wolf Cull officially announced somewhere?