Jump to content

Recommended Posts

 

 

 

Which parts of his armour are MkX? I can see only almost primaris-seized Firstborn. The mini’s cool, tho.

What part of the lore says that Primaris have to wear Mk X? They don't have a special black carapace. Plus you can put Primaris in the Armour Indomitus which pre-dates the Heresy so this is a non-arguement.

'Cause they don't fit in previous armour marks due to their superior size, compared to dwarf-marines?

I imagine some of the bigger firstborn are as big as some of the smaller Primaris. They're not all the same exact height in the lore.

 

 

The whole size differential thing shoulda never made into lore.

 

Classic marines being ugly midgets was always due to historical baggage in the model designs and the historical choice of 'heroic scale'.

 

It has no place in any lore depictions where marines always were super tall.  But we have to obsess over size ("Marines are 8 feet tall!, Custodes are even taller at 9 feet!, and primarchs even taller at 10! And the emprs he was even taller and could self-tall himself at will!") So when newer taller marines arrive, they got to be taller in lore too right? 

 

The marine entallment project GW embarked upon also included a gear update, and was given an in lore name as a new breed of marine which pretty much was a mistake. I'm on the primaris train not because the name means anything to me, but that's where the new models are being brought in. Besides that I just want the distinction between OG and Primaris to die off already.

 

 

 

 

Which parts of his armour are MkX? I can see only almost primaris-seized Firstborn. The mini’s cool, tho.

What part of the lore says that Primaris have to wear Mk X? They don't have a special black carapace. Plus you can put Primaris in the Armour Indomitus which pre-dates the Heresy so this is a non-arguement.

'Cause they don't fit in previous armour marks due to their superior size, compared to dwarf-marines?

Go tell that to the giant Firstborn like Silas Albrect of the Exorcists.

 

 

The whole size differential thing shoulda never made into lore.

 

Classic marines being ugly midgets was always due to historical baggage in the model designs and the historical choice of 'heroic scale'.

 

It has no place in any lore depictions where marines always were super tall.  But we have to obsess over size ("Marines are 8 feet tall!, Custodes are even taller at 9 feet!, and primarchs even taller at 10! And the emprs he was even taller and could self-tall himself at will!") So when newer taller marines arrive, they got to be taller in lore too right? 

 

The marine entallment project GW embarked upon also included a gear update, and was given an in lore name as a new breed of marine which pretty much was a mistake. I'm on the primaris train not because the name means anything to me, but that's where the new models are being brought in. Besides that I just want the distinction between OG and Primaris to die off already.

 

 

I've rather enjoyed the whole lore aspect of Primaris as it's been fleshed out, it explained the massive influx in marines which was needed to boost the imperium back into contention post the rift, it also explained the new toys, as well as added an interesting element to the backstories of the various Primaris Marines. Often the juxtaposition between their outlooks, often from more enlightened times, has given an interesting insight into events.

 

 

 

 

 

The whole size differential thing shoulda never made into lore.

 

Classic marines being ugly midgets was always due to historical baggage in the model designs and the historical choice of 'heroic scale'.

 

It has no place in any lore depictions where marines always were super tall. But we have to obsess over size ("Marines are 8 feet tall!, Custodes are even taller at 9 feet!, and primarchs even taller at 10! And the emprs he was even taller and could self-tall himself at will!") So when newer taller marines arrive, they got to be taller in lore too right?

 

The marine entallment project GW embarked upon also included a gear update, and was given an in lore name as a new breed of marine which pretty much was a mistake. I'm on the primaris train not because the name means anything to me, but that's where the new models are being brought in. Besides that I just want the distinction between OG and Primaris to die off already.

 

I've rather enjoyed the whole lore aspect of Primaris as it's been fleshed out, it explained the massive influx in marines which was needed to boost the imperium back into contention post the rift, it also explained the new toys, as well as added an interesting element to the backstories of the various Primaris Marines. Often the juxtaposition between their outlooks, often from more enlightened times, has given an interesting insight into events.

Arguably it also adds some grimdark into Marine stories which have more of a tendancy to devolve into bolter porn.

 

 

 

 

The whole size differential thing shoulda never made into lore.

 

Classic marines being ugly midgets was always due to historical baggage in the model designs and the historical choice of 'heroic scale'.

 

It has no place in any lore depictions where marines always were super tall. But we have to obsess over size ("Marines are 8 feet tall!, Custodes are even taller at 9 feet!, and primarchs even taller at 10! And the emprs he was even taller and could self-tall himself at will!") So when newer taller marines arrive, they got to be taller in lore too right?

 

The marine entallment project GW embarked upon also included a gear update, and was given an in lore name as a new breed of marine which pretty much was a mistake. I'm on the primaris train not because the name means anything to me, but that's where the new models are being brought in. Besides that I just want the distinction between OG and Primaris to die off already.

 

I've rather enjoyed the whole lore aspect of Primaris as it's been fleshed out, it explained the massive influx in marines which was needed to boost the imperium back into contention post the rift, it also explained the new toys, as well as added an interesting element to the backstories of the various Primaris Marines. Often the juxtaposition between their outlooks, often from more enlightened times, has given an interesting insight into events.

I think it’s been handled well in lore, and I always try to keep in mind that the lore follows GW biz decisions not the other way around. GW wants to sell more models leads to: revamp the highest selling line into “true scale” leads to: make up a story to make this decision fit into the fiction. As a fan of the primaris aesthetic (dwarf marines look goofy to me now) I’m glad they did it. I’m looking forward to firstborn and primaris getting split into separate codecies. That book is getting too damn big.

Edited by Amocat

 

 

 

Which parts of his armour are MkX? I can see only almost primaris-seized Firstborn. The mini’s cool, tho.

What part of the lore says that Primaris have to wear Mk X? They don't have a special black carapace. Plus you can put Primaris in the Armour Indomitus which pre-dates the Heresy so this is a non-arguement.

'Cause they don't fit in previous armour marks due to their superior size, compared to dwarf-marines?

Go tell that to the giant Firstborn like Silas Albrect of the Exorcists.

Or Alexis Polux, in Dornian lineage.

 

 

 

 

 

Which parts of his armour are MkX? I can see only almost primaris-seized Firstborn. The mini’s cool, tho.

What part of the lore says that Primaris have to wear Mk X? They don't have a special black carapace. Plus you can put Primaris in the Armour Indomitus which pre-dates the Heresy so this is a non-arguement.
'Cause they don't fit in previous armour marks due to their superior size, compared to dwarf-marines?
Go tell that to the giant Firstborn like Silas Albrect of the Exorcists.
Or Alexis Polux, in Dornian lineage.

Aren't the Exorcists sons of Dorn themselves?

Edited by Odd-ad
Either way, as Fulkes and Reclusiarch Krieg have said, we have had large firstborn before, and if I recall correctly the primaris aren't supposed to be too much taller in-universe. So a firstborn as tall as a primaris marine isn't too much of a stretch
I think it’s very telling that in the most recent codex the only firstborn infantry models shown are bespoke chapter specific. I think once primaris gets its unit slots filled (flyer etc) they get their own codex. Edited by Amocat

 

 

 

Which parts of his armour are MkX? I can see only almost primaris-seized Firstborn. The mini’s cool, tho.

What part of the lore says that Primaris have to wear Mk X? They don't have a special black carapace. Plus you can put Primaris in the Armour Indomitus which pre-dates the Heresy so this is a non-arguement.

'Cause they don't fit in previous armour marks due to their superior size, compared to dwarf-marines?

Go tell that to the giant Firstborn like Silas Albrect of the Exorcists.

 

In current timeline, huge Pasanius of Ultramarines uses parts of Mark X armour. Previously, iirc, it was stated that his armour was partly TDA :rolleyes: . Still, Pasanius is dwarfed by transformed Uriel Ventris.

=][= This is so far off-topic it needs to stop; the primaris debate can be had elsewhere, if people are really desperate to beat that dead horse some more. =][=

Even if I love the idea of Vow and Passion but it feels strange if it's our super doctrine to got a strong debuff on it. Yeah we got the choice to take what we want but, the old abhor the witch look better. And the Accept any challenge look strong !

 

But don't know if it's strong enough for some player to don't be able to fall (and Shock Assault didn't work anymore with this vow).

 

It's really a good and heavy fluff stuff, I love it, since I started to play due to the fluff... But for more competitive player it gonna be borring I think !

To get us somewhat back on track with rumours, do we think GW will drop the new Ancient model randomly like they did they chaos sorcerer down the line after the CSM release or do you think they’re waiting to just before? People that have seen the models before hand were surprised by the Castellan so a surprise could still be around the corner too

Are we still thinking that is going to happen? The last video was listed as being the full release so it would seem really odd for them to still have models left to show. If there was going to be any model left until after the full release was revealed I would have thought it was the blanche castellan due to the nostalgia associated with it.

 

I am still slightly hoping it might be an option in the SB kit similar to the custodes terminators being able to make a captain and banner as well, but I'm not hopeful

The only reason I’m holding out hope is that people have said they’ve seen the actual model based on the old art work, and they haven’t been wrong or lied once as of yet

 

That would be cool to be fair, I’m thinking it’ll be a splash release further down the line though as is becoming the trend

Brothers, Hold on to your zeal.

 

Because, Next week we will see the Honorable Ancient Holding our Chapter Banner High!

 

Do Not get in personal glory, for that is the way of the heresy!

 

Glory belongs to our Chapter, To Sigismund, To Dorn and The Emperor only!

 

We serve to give it to them! 

 

No Pity, No Remorse, No Fear!

Either way, as Fulkes and Reclusiarch Krieg have said, we have had large firstborn before, and if I recall correctly the primaris aren't supposed to be too much taller in-universe. So a firstborn as tall as a primaris marine isn't too much of a stretch

Or older marks of power armour being large enough to fit Primaris sitting in the armoury.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.