Let The Galaxy Burn! Balefire Legion: 40k again!

[Dragonlover]

Yeah, Rule of Cool trumps all. Keep the trim.

 

Dragonlover

[Khornestar]

Please don't tone it down. There are no rules being broken, here. It looks incredible. I'm quite sure we don't know the background information of units you're creating from your imagination.

[SkimaskMohawk]

I wouldn't tone it down either, to be honest: Let's not forget that the Word Bearers used something like this as early as Isstvan V. By the time the Siege of Terra came rolling around, more than one Primarch had ascended to daemonhood, the Death Guard had mutated into shambling mounds of decay, the Gal Vorbak were all over the place -- there cannot have been any doubt as to the powers behind Horus' rebellion, so chaotic trim seems pretty plausible to me. Plus it looks awesome

 

They didn't, actually, they made it from a wrecked dread they pulled from isstvan V.

 

Well converted chaos stuff is awesome, but personally I don't really see the point of going to 30k to just swap a scheme if its still going to be as blatantly chaotic as its 40k counter parts

Edited December 18, 2015 by SkimaskMohawk

[Teetengee]

 

I wouldn't tone it down either, to be honest: Let's not forget that the Word Bearers used something like this as early as Isstvan V. By the time the Siege of Terra came rolling around, more than one Primarch had ascended to daemonhood, the Death Guard had mutated into shambling mounds of decay, the Gal Vorbak were all over the place -- there cannot have been any doubt as to the powers behind Horus' rebellion, so chaotic trim seems pretty plausible to me. Plus it looks awesome

 

They didn't, actually, they made it from a wrecked dread they pulled from isstvan V.

 

Well converted chaos stuff is awesome, but personally I don't really see the point of going to 30k to just swap a scheme if its still going to be as blatantly chaotic as its 40k counter parts

 

shhhh ;)

 

You have a point, I just think the model looks too cool to remove them.

[Quixus]

I wouldn't tone it down either, to be honest: Let's not forget that the Word Bearers used something like this as early as Isstvan V. By the time the Siege of Terra came rolling around, more than one Primarch had ascended to daemonhood, the Death Guard had mutated into shambling mounds of decay, the Gal Vorbak were all over the place -- there cannot have been any doubt as to the powers behind Horus' rebellion, so chaotic trim seems pretty plausible to me. Plus it looks awesome

I never took those trim strips (with the arrows) as manifestations of the warp but just a style that was en vogue before and during the Heresy. Now if a couple of the rivets were replaced by eyes or tentacles....

[SkimaskMohawk]

The arrows never appear on the heresy armours, I'm pretty sure the arrows are a representation of the arrows off the chaos star; it would only start popping up consistently once a lot of marines start to worship the pantheon as a whole (i.e. once they're in the eye)

[AlphariusOmegon108]

The arrows never appear on the heresy armours, I'm pretty sure the arrows are a representation of the arrows off the chaos star; it would only start popping up consistently once a lot of marines start to worship the pantheon as a whole (i.e. once they're in the eye)

wrong. The arrow also repeatedly appears on pre heresy/unification war armor, look at the classic model for the MK1 representation in the "Armor through the ages" set from GW, alot of arrows on there. But no chaos.

[Khornestar]

Maybe we can save the silly fluff arguments for places other than someone else's project log?

[KrautScientist]

Maybe we can save the silly fluff arguments for places other than someone else's project log?

 

This. Personally, I think the Contemptor seems like a very suitable representation of a late Heresy Sons of Horus warmachine. Plus the armour trim has just been beautifully executed, as I said earlier. One thing that only occured to me now: You will still need to do something about those gaps on the side of the legs where the parts go together. The effect makes for a rather jarring contrast with the excellently clean trim right now.

[Teetengee]

Can we summon a mod to excise and move the fluff discussion elsewhere? It is probably itself worthy of merit.

[thamier]

so much that i cent even start to comment on it all, i dont mind the disgussion, its interesting to hear the reasoning of why or why not, i keept thinking of the discription of when logen finds the "temple" on the vengfulspirit hidden behind a old banner and the stars of chaos shown there right?

 

also Ks thinking of modding the helm and all the gaps are filled but wont show until it has paint case its transparaent glue that filled all those ;)

[SkimaskMohawk]

I think the main thing to consider is if you want to continue doing really awesome chaos conversions or if you want to do really awesome 30k conversions. Because, honestly, it'll just look like normal CSM with all the arrow trim 

[Augustus b'Raass]

Thamier, that's really some very well executed contemptor trim you've got going there. I'll echo others about the kinda dull head, but other than that I can't wait for you to paint this and show us your 30K scheme. One tiny point though: that weapon combination sucks. Better get two of either shooties, or combine one with a fist.

 

@SkimaskMohawk: As Teetengee said, the discussion of pointy armour trim being 30K is interesting indeed and worthy of discussion, but you've exhaustively made your point versus thamier's contemptor, SkimaskMohawk. If you want to continue, I suggest you open a thread about it in the HH section.

[thamier]

i think ill do some modification to the head, and gonna tone the conversions down a little on the others wanted two heavely chaosyfied contemptors one half chaos and one unmodified, but think ill change that to the next two only partly chaosyfied. also unsure of paint scheme.

if i should modify it to fit my 40k army like keep the green and ither make the red parts like cloth and topnots grey to match my black legion.

and the first companys will be black armoured ofc.

 

and as mentioned esrlyer i will make one or two transition units that be 50/50 SoH and balefire legion coloured and converted

[Teetengee]

Perhaps your balefire legion were some of the first to really embrace chaos? Lots of room for differences in individual companies during the heresy.

[thamier]

so you dont think it be too much of a imersion break to go with grey instead of red?

[MagicMan]

That contemptor looks awesome! Dont tone it down! ;)

[Teetengee]

red? where does red come from?

[thamier]

the red topknots and any cloth seems to be red on Sons of Horus

[Teetengee]

ah, that makes sense

Black or Sea Green is generally what I think of as their colour, hence my confusion

[Soric]

I think the idea of using grey for details is a good one, afterall as Teetengee said there's lots of room for differentiation for individual companies during the heresy. The grey would be a strong visual clue as to who'll they'll become eventually. Also nice work on the chaosy bling for the contemptor btw.

[Khornestar]

so you dont think it be too much of a imersion break to go with grey instead of red?

IMO continuity between your 30k and 40k armies would increase immersion. Consider that out of hundreds of thousands (or whatever) of heresy era legionnaires, we've had a minority described to us directly. Who's to say your slice of that pie is wrong? I think there could be no greater way to forge the proverbial narrative than to take ownership of the background and create an army's story over a 10,000+ year span, the way you've done. Some might feel this is "doing it wrong" and that's not an invalid point of view, but to me it seems strange to take the fluff of a fictional universe so seriously that one thinks there is even a right or wrong way to begin with.

[thamier]

 

so you dont think it be too much of a imersion break to go with grey instead of red?

IMO continuity between your 30k and 40k armies would increase immersion. Consider that out of hundreds of thousands (or whatever) of heresy era legionnaires, we've had a minority described to us directly. Who's to say your slice of that pie is wrong? I think there could be no greater way to forge the proverbial narrative than to take ownership of the background and create an army's story over a 10,000+ year span, the way you've done. Some might feel this is "doing it wrong" and that's not an invalid point of view, but to me it seems strange to take the fluff of a fictional universe so seriously that one thinks there is even a right or wrong way to begin with.

 

 

what about paniting Horus's cloak grey? since he is a major character

[Khornestar]

The warmaster surely has the resources to keep a vast collection of cloaks. ;)

 

"It's Monday, Abaddon. I think I'll wear the grey one today."

Edited December 21, 2015 by Venomlust

[thamier]

The warmaster surely has the resources to keep a vast collection of cloaks.

 

"It's Monday, Abaddon. I think I'll wear the grey one today."

 

now that made me smile!